##VIDEO ID:XNwJH1uitZo## good morning we'll give just a moment to clear the waiting room good morning this is the voting hearing of the licensing board for the city of Boston today is Thursday September 26 2024 this hearing is being recorded and will be posted to the city of Boston's website while the public is encouraged to attend there will be no additional testimony accepted this morning we'll begin with the licensed premise inspection hearing which occurred on Tuesday September 24th 2024 item number one Concord entertainment Inc doing business as bills bar the landown pub located at N9 lown Street date of the incident January 20th 2024 assault and battery employee on Patron in violation of Mass general laws chap 138 section 64 and chapter 265 section 13A I'll I'll begin thanks Danny um I did review the video um and I reviewed the testimony from the hearing on Tuesday I was not able to determine how this uh fight started or who the initial aggressor was I do think the security was involved in the tussle in some way but I'm not quite sure how it all began um for those reasons I see no violation uh I agree I just didn't think there was enough based on everything we had not that I wasn't concerned I think this is kind of a case of like U who deserves the benefit of the doubt and reasonable inferences uh that's really what I was weighing um but my concern is that you know we kind of just had them for uh employee on Patron and with the video I wasn't satisfied with the the the supposed blind spot seems like this area of the bar would be covered by a camera this is the you know kind of the front as the exit is so I I did have no violation but me you know based solely on lack of evidence and you know the the alleged victims weren't in front of us so it was just a evidentiary kind of lacking um but I do want to have some sort of account accountability for this blind spot I I don't know if it's acceptable or they should explain why it's there and whether they can fix it or or what I'm not inclined to give them the benefit of the doubt if this happens again and something with their security happens in this big blind spot so I think we should put them on notice about that also really curious about that blind spot maybe there's some correspondence that that talks about you know the importance of having um you know good camera syst system and then also just deescalation as well I agree um Danny if we could include this on the docup sheet so that it's uh should they come before for us again with the same explanation it's in a blind spot we can refer to the fact that we've addressed this on the record and we've corresponded with them um I don't know at this point if we can force them to change where the cameras are but it's something we should think about as a board if if there continues to be a problem here I think you raised very good points Commissioners so it sounds like no violation dock it that the incident happened in a blind spot that the cameras could not catch and also send correspondents about the fact that this occurred in a blind spot um suggest that they have cameras to cover that spot and also the importance of deescalation yes great moving on to item number two Food House Inc doing business as friendship BBQ aluson located at 103 Brighton a in alustin date of the incident April 27th 2024 Assa and battery with a dangerous weapon a bottle Patron on Patron in viol of Mass general laws chapter 138 section 64 and chapter 265 section 15a I did not see any violation here I agree I agree as well item number three Za a KF L LLC doing business as Garis Columbia located at 28 Bennington Street in East Boston date of the incident June 22nd 2024 salt and Battery employee on Patron in violation of Mass general laws chapter 138 section 64 and chapter 265 section 13A the video and the explanation from the staff was helpful um I did not see a [Music] violation um I didn't see a violation but I thought it was closer than they portrayed it yeah I didn't think the patrons were as threatening especially like with the chair I don't know if that Patron was threatening the chair was like slid away not used as a weapon um I thought it was kind of a borderline situation and you know standard correspondence about deescalation and you know not using physical Force unless it's um proportional I agree so no violation with correspondents about the importance of deescalation and just to make sure the correspondence is included in the docket sheet so we can refer to it we'll do item number four zaa KFL LLC doing business as bis Columbia located at 28 Bennington Street in East Boston date of the incident August 18th 2024 bottle service violation in violation of Mass general laws chapter 138 section 64 absolute violation here easy one y um sorry commissioner agree okay they had just been before us I think what two weeks before this they received a first warning then um because we have um Progressive discipline I feel like I can't go beyond a second warning here however I think it's pretty egregious that two weeks later there before us again for this same violation I'm not quite sure their explanation adds up to now they're putting cff of water on the table I think it's a real slippery slope but um I'm on the record saying I think this is a second written warning right did they say they they were using cffs though I I think they said they were trying to use a different bottle but maybe I I misheard it wasn't clear to me neither here nor there the needed that final question just to be clear was our Gren on the table yes okay thank you that's all yeah the rest of the stuff I don't know if it mattered that much so just to make sure I correctly violation the second warning is that correct I think so yeah okay thank you item number five Salona Sports Association located at 26 Fleet Street date of the incident August 16th 2024 overcrowding 71 on count capacity 49 house count 48 in violation of Mass General law chter 138 section 64 and Boards rule 1.03 J and 1.06 a and F this was on a special one-day alcohol license I do see a violation for the overcrowding um I think that explanation made sense they weren't properly staffed um my vote is for a warning and written correspondence should they apply again for the same event next year I'd like to see a written plan explaining how they're going to control the crowds I agree right and if that needs to be docketed in order for you to see that warning then great so violation the warning will be docketed that any future applications for a special one day must include a written plan for controlling the capacity and written correspondent saying the same and item six Causeway Union LLC doing business as loyal n located at 17 Union Street date of the incident June 13th 2024 assult and Battery on premise in violation of Mass general laws CH 138 section 64 in chapter 265 section 13A I'll begin um so after two hearings on this issue it's still unclear to me who was actually in charge on this night and who the manager of record was on the night in question without a doubt without a doubt an assault and battery occurred um so I'm going to say I see an absolute violation there for that um going towards whether or not this assault and battery is foreseeable in my opinion yes it was this is a place with a history of poor management and supervision an employee actually committed an assault on the premise it's not a mitigating factor that he worked there and they're still in a dating relationship and all seems okay you can't bring them onto the hearing and say oh it was a misunderstanding I was really black out drunk that night as a manager or a management staff there's a duty of care owed to your employees and to the public there was a clear and undeniable breakdown of management and supervision here and we've seen this before with these uh managers this woman in my opinion is lucky to be alive based on the video evidence that was provided to the board and let me make a note that video evidence was provided to the board because I believe somebody went in with their own cell phone and videoed the security cameras and that is why the management turned it over to the board um sure they provided that to the third party but I still don't think we would have gotten it unless un we had subpoenaed it or unless the police had turned it over um there was no call to the police as is required by our rules with anyone who was injured on a license premise there was conflicting statements on the record about whether the employee perpetrator was fired or resigned which I take issue with um but the point is we know they're attempting to sell this license which we all think or I think we would all agree is is for the public good um my last last Point here is that while I am not um going to delve into the character and Fitness today of the owners in the management staff I do have questions about whether anyone involved in this business as a manager as a member of the LLC as a staff person has the appropriate character and fitness to serve in a management role in any licensed establishment in the city of Austin I have grave concerns about the people involved in this license and will continue to monitor closely the activities at their other license premises but um those are my comments I can let the other Commissioners comment first or if You' like me to go into what my motion is and my proposal is let me know Danny uh that could go either way commissioner K commissioner Z do you have any comments before we move to a poal discipline what I would say is um I agree with everything the chair said I would uh couple of things that I noted I would like noted is the first thing is the young woman it was a patron not an employee she had just been refused service and somehow she's in the back and a non-public area so that's something else I noticed about you know how this was uh a failure and foreseeable and and how the bar contributed to this Assa battery second thing uh I noted was that really what the two uh people who testified trying to justify what we saw on the video we trying to get at was some sort of um you know that the on its face the conduct that we saw was clear battery that what they're trying to say is it's justifiable under the law and so what I'm seeing is you know they're trying to present some sort of self-defense Andor defense of others probably defense of others what the testimony really lacked uh between both of them was any kind of assertion that someone was in physical danger whether it be the young woman or another party uh really what they were getting at was that he was trying to save her from a confrontation from embarrassment from making a scene um that explanation does not justify the amount of physical force that we saw so you know for me under the law there their kind of justification for it would fail um it should have failed when management reviewed conduct uh and you know therefore even if we were to accept that what they were saying is true which I serious doubts about it still wouldn't rise the level of being justifiable you know on illegal contact so um I noted that um I think that's all I had in addition I everything you said I was noting as well so I think that's all I have actually I agree with everything and I think that um it's also um important to note that they actually admitted that they wanted to bury the video and that they thought that it was a quote unquote Private Matter and so that that just um speaks to the lack of judgment and I think um you know often in the cases where there is a very clear violation we really do take into account the Contrition of um the parties and here there was defense and you know a complete lack of accountability and so that I think should also be noted for the record I did have one more thing sorry uh unless I'm mistaken I believe that Mr Brady told me he had Source videos after a lot of confusion I thought we got to the point where he said he had Source videos and we got not Source videos we got videos of videos uh with only a tiny little bit extra of what we could see it was um the only additional footage that I could note was uh it was a different angle at the end of one of the videos where you could more clearly see her running away yeah I agree with you commissioner K even though we asked the question several times on the record and in writing I don't think Mr Brady understood what we meant as far as we wanted videos from the cameras for some reason that didn't process clearly with him and we continued to get the same cell phone videos um and he says he has no access to the establishment so he has um no access to the videos which really troubles me um because he still is the manager there um and unless someone went and Destroy them I would believe that he could obtain them for us um we've said in the past that an incident like this is it that the reaction should be to save all videos and he went there the next night I have I have um people who have called me to say he showed up at the door the next night or the night after two nights later and he was aware of this incident um he could have gone down and preserve the videos then he is a seasoned um owner of licenses in the city of Boston and in other communities he knows very well what his responsibilities are and commissioner um Liam I think was being very clear and very straight bored about what the request was and so I don't think that there was any room for confusion I think it was deliberate because they he he said it you know I I spoke to them they're friends of mine so like it was a it was a very complete lack of judgment and and and it's almost like a conflict of interest because he you know he wanted to protect them as friends and so he shered his duty as a minority partner and as someone who is very used to being a manager as well he understood that that um commissioner Liam wanted the The Source video all that being said yeah with with all the comments on the record um is there a a proposal for um disposition of the violation it sounds like there is a violation across the board unanimously yes um my suggestion or my vote would be for an indefinite suspension only to be lifted should this license be sold to a party that is not involved in this license I totally agree whole wholeheartedly agree absolutely the license is indefinitely suspended only to be lifted uh by a transfer to an unrelated entity thank you all moving on to the transactional hearing which occurred yesterday Wednesday September 25th 2024 item number one Enterprise kg LLC doing business as the munchie station located at 966 Dorchester AV in Dorchester has applied for a common vit license manager Kevin Gonzalez hours of operation 8: am to 11: PM I vote to approve I agree I agree as well item two aayan LLC doing business as Oba bakery located at 16 Brighton a in Alon manager adab aayan hours of operation 7: am to 900m I vote to approve I agree I agree as well item number three s Family Group LLC doing business as McDonald's located at 100 Legends way has petitioned to change the closing hour to 3:00 a.m. uh with deliveries only from 12:00 a.m. to 3:00 a.m. I vote to approve the extension um of the closing hour however I would like to put on the face of the license where deliveries should be which I believe is the nashille street no deliveries of the nashille street pedestrian corridor sounds good than great granted with the condition that no deliveries to take place in the natural Street pedestrian Corridor item number four the Newman School located at 298 to 300 Newbury Street has applied for a lodging house dormatory license manager Michael schaer I vote to approve I agree I agree item five Commonwealth Land Trust doing business as to 50 cver Street LLC located at 250 cver street in Dorchester has applied for a lodging house license manager Dina Herrera I vote to approve I agree I agree item six nkotb lesie LLC doing business as R Hotel Rebels Guild located at 196 to 200 Stewart Street as petion to change the manager to Shan how I vote to approve Mr how as manager record I believe he has the appropriate character and fitness to serve I agree agree item seven Del Frisco of Boston LLC doing business as Del Frisco located at 230 Northern a has petitioned to change the manager to Michael vitki I vote to approve Mr blitzky as manager record I believe he has the appropriate character and fitness to serve I agree agree it number eight Clover Ventures LLC doing business as Bostonia Public House located at 131 State Street has petition to pledge the license to Northern Bank and Trust Company I vote to approve the pledge I agree I agree item number nine SSP America Inc doing business as pets at night located at 500 Terminal Road in East Boston with in Logan Airport Terminal E has petitioned to change the closing hour to 12 a.m. I vote to approve the change in the closing hour I agree I agree item number 10 Cafe delos sport Inc doing business as Cafe delos sport located at 308 Handover Street has petitioned to change the manager to Myan Spencer petitioned for a change of officers directors and has petitioned for a change of stock interest I vote to approve Mr Spencer as manager of record I believe he has the appropriate character Fitness to serve and I also vote to approve the change of officers and directors and the change of stock interest I agree I agree item number 11 326 B LLC doing business as red fox located at 326 to 328 Commercial Street has petitioned to amend the description of the licensed business to three rooms and Kitchen on basement level of 326 to 328 Commercial Street with dining areas and seated bar 11 seats at the bar in front room together with additional dining area and seated raw bar with seven seats at the second bar with alcohol service storage and office space and wine seller 2,868 ft total secondly has petitioned to change the DBA to Red Fox and extra dirty um I vote to approve the amended description and the change of DBA I agree I agree item number 12 cpcb LLC doing business as Cornish py located at 51a massav has petitioned to transfer the license to Yoshida omaz llc at the same location Gabrielle morso manager 12 a.m. closing hour and is also petitioned to update the description of the premise to street level and basement level contain 2276 ft first level is for dining ADA Compliant bathroom kitchen and preparation areas basement level is for storage separate preparation area and Dish cleaning washing street level has one doorway for Ingress and egress and basement level has a second doorway for Ingress egress for delivery of all supplies I vote to approve the transfer I vote to approve Miss marso as manager of record I believe she is the appropriate character and fitness to serve I also vote to approve the updated description and I think that's it I agree I agree thank you item number 13 laroka Inc doing business as Dolce Vita located at 221 Handover Street has petitioned to transfer the license to Martin edti Restaurant Group LLC doing business as bar martinetti at the same location Robert martinetti manager 12:00 a.m. closing hour has also petition to update the description of the premise two in one room on first floor comprised of various dining areas bar bar and restroom in rear together with additional dining room restrooms kitchen and storage in the basement 3590 ft total and finally has petitioned to remove a condition from the license that requires malt and wine both URS to be served only in conjunction with meals I vote to approve the transfer at the same location I vote to approve Mr martinetti as manager of record I believe he has the appropriate character and fitness to serve I vote to update the description and to remove the condition I agree I agree thank you item number 14 Cannonball Cafe LLC doing business as Cannonball Cafe located at 383 doorchester AV in South Boston has petitioned to transfer the license to 383 lot LLC doing business as Park City at the same location Michael Shaw manager 12:00 a.m. closing hour has also petitioned to amend the description to premise cons comprised of an approximately 30,000 ft outdoor space and 2579 ft of interior space for storage coolers and prep space outdoor space with one bar with seating for 40 two bars for walkup service various tables Cabana stadium and other types of seating for 440 structure for food service and space for lawn games activities and Stage for live music and finally a addition to pledge the license to Cannonball Cafe LLC um I think this is a great use of this space um it's currently being activated on a a special event um um through a special event through special events but I think this is a permanent a great permanent activation of a space that um is going to bring a lot of um good use to the community so my vote would be to approve the transfer of the license to approve well Mr Shaw's already An approved manager record to approve the um amended description and to approve the pledge yeah I mean there were some concerns raised but I don't even know if we can consider them with a Corp to Corp at the same location um you know maybe not maybe I mean that what was raised is certainly sounds concerning but I think we have to rely on the proper environmental agencies to you know oversee that that's really not our purview maybe it would have been the first time we approved this location but not a cour to cour the same location so um I go to approve yeah I I can vote to approve as well and hopefully they can uh continue some sort of community process to vet out all the uh issues and concerns uh transfer is approved item number 15 turnaround Sushi Inc doing business as crave mad for chicken located at 75 neand Street has petitioned to transfer the license and the location to Huna Inc doing business as kala Tai cookery located at 151 Handover Street Manita buag getar manager 12 12 a.m. closing hour I vote to approve the transfer um I also vote to approve Manita as manager of record I believe she has the appropriate character and fitness to serve I agree I agree item 16 goggle moggle Inc doing business as Sea Biscuit located at 256 Marginal Street in East Boston has petitioned to transfer the license and the location to selfup LLC doing business as selfup cooking classes located at 19 Kingston Street Valentino paradin manager 10 p.m. closing hour and has also petitioned to change the license type to a general on premise um I vote to approve um this transfer of the license to this location um and I vote to approve Mr paraden as manager of record um I believe they're going to come back and change the manager record again soon um and I also uh vote to change the license type I agree I agree items 17 and 18 Boston Winery LLC doing business as Boston Winery located at 26 Ericson Street in Dorchester item 17 is an application for a farmer Brewery pouring license under section 19 C of chapter 138 and item 18 is for a combined wall wines and malts pouring license uh under section 19h of chapter 138 Ralph Bruno manager 11:00 p.m. closing hour I vote to approve Mr Bruno as manager um and I vote to approve the uh pouring licenses I agree I agree on the last one did did we have to say that they were going to turn on turn in the previous license was that the one where she Bly said that that she was going to turn in the no that was um that that was on the application for an all out license for local okay sorry about that no no worries uh items 19 and 20 shamit Hudson LLC doing business as Trillium located at 401 Park Drive item 19 is an application for a farmer Distillery pouring license under section 19e of chapter 138 and item 20 is an application for a combined wines malts and Distillery pouring license under section 19h of chapter 138 Brandon keading manager 1: a.m closing hour I vote to approve the pouring licenses I believe everything else um we've already approved Mr keing that's correct I do as well I agree item number 21 Walter Corporation doing business as El hardine located at 15 William C Kelly Square in East Boston has applied for a common vict or 7-Day wines and M beverages license manager Kelly Oro Closing Time 2 am um so this is an application for an East Boston beer and wine license at a Colombian restaurant um that is they've been open for 20 years four years with this management um I believe the manager record has the appropriate character and fitness to serve and I do believe they did they established public need for a beer and wine license at this location I agree I agree right so so the vote is um I'm sorry so I vote to approve the license pending the availability for one of one for which they qualify yes great thank you item number 22 florenza Inc doing business as florenza located at 164 to 170 Su Street in East Boston has applied for a common vict or 7day Wines in M beverages with Lor's license manager Stefano Bruno Closing Time 10 p.m. thanks this is another East Boston application for a baron Line license this is an Italian uh concept um in on the waterfront in East Boston um I do believe this is a neighborhood that is growing and I do believe they could sustain another restaurant that offers beer and wine to their patrons um my vote is to approve Mr Bruno as manager record I believe is the appropriate character in Fitness to serve and my vote would be to approve this application p ing the availability of a license for which they qualify I agree I agree and item number 23 local Inc doing business as local located at 350 to 352 Handover Street has applied for a common victual or 7-Day all alcoholic beverages license manager Jennifer matazo Closing Time 11: p.m. this is an application for an all alcohol license in the North End at an establishment that currently has beer and wine um I think Miss mzo is already the approved manager record so I don't have to get into her qualifications I think they made a compelling argument that this is both a neighborhood and a busy tourist area this is a modern Pizzeria I know most of the restaurants in the North End are Italian focused but I do believe when you break apart what the offerings are here um with an expanded bar this is an amenity that not all the restaurants in the North End offer their patrons you can sit at the bar and have food can sit a loan as they mentioned um and it was described as a gourmet pizza place so for all of those reasons my vote would be to approve it pending the availability of a license for which they qualify um so those are my comments in my vote um I would second all that I would make the approval contingent on the return of the the beer wine thank you yep I agree I tried to pin it on someone on another matter so yes I agree sounds like granted pending availability if a license is available and issued the ly must surrender the existing uh Feer line in the cor's license yes thank you for that um for reminding me of that thank you moving on to non-hearing transactions the following are applying for a new common vular license at a previously licensed location item number one sarva Foods Corp doing business as sarva located at 279 Newbury Street manager suas Naik hours of operation 10:00 a.m. to 9:00 p.m. I vote to approve I agree I agree item number two JC and Friends Inc doing business as K chicken located at 86 Peterboro Street manager chenit prow sitol hours of operation 11:00 a. to 11: p.m. I vote to approve I do as well I agree item number three push cart popout LLC doing business as soul on shamut located at 772 shamut AV in roxburry manager Iman Abdul musir L montin hour of operation 7:00 am. to 10 p.m I vote to approve I agree agree item number four mum Mish LLC doing business as mum Mish located at five Bowden Street in Dorchester manager Jillian Niles hours of operation 6 amm to 900 P PM I vote to approve I agree I agree and item number five Medford coffee LLC doing business as Duncan located at 39 first AV in Charlestown manager chinia norer hours of operation 5: am to 7M I vote to approve I agree agree following uh have applied for a one-day amendment to their existing license item number one Mass Bay Brewing Company Inc doing business as Harpoon Brewery located at 306 Northern AV has applied to include the parking lot surrounding the brewery for Harpoon o October Fest and dogtober Fest on October 4th from 6:00 to 11:00 p.m. October 5th from 12:00 to 7:00 p.m. and October 6th from 10:00 a.m. to 2m vote to approve I agree agree item two a d Inc doing business as Ned divines located at 2201 Fel Hall Marketplace has applied to include the contiguous space in the upper rotunda of quiny Market building for a rose keny Greenway reception on October 1st from 4: to 6: p.m. vote to approve I agree I agree item number three similarly ad Inc doing business as Ned divines at 2201 FAL Hall Marketplace has applied to include the same contiguous space in the upper rotund of quinsey market for a reception for the American Cancer Society on October 10th from 4: to 7: p.m. I vote to approve I agree I agree item four Cisco Brewers distillers ventner seport Inc doing business as Cisco seport located at 85 Northern AV has applied to uh seek an earlier opening hour 1 hour earlier on October 13th beginning at 11:00 a.m. for the Post party for the Martin Richards Foundation MK Road Race I vote to approve I do as well I agree item five Notch Notch Brighton Tap Room LLC located at 1420 to 1440 Soldiers Field Road in Brighton has applied to include an outside Courtyard for a vendor Market on October 10th from 6:00 to 8:00 p.m. and October 20th from 5: to 10: p.m. my vote to approve I agree I agree and item number six AHF Speedway Holdings LLC doing business as the Charles River Speedway located at 1420 to 1440 Soldiers Field Road in Brighton has applied to extend their patio for the month of October specifically October 1st through 19th 21st to 29th and 31st from 12: p.m. to 11 p.m I vote to approve I agree I agree board has before them a list of applications for special one-day alcoholic beverages uh which have been administratively reviewed by staff and approved by the board and three items for a vote on old and new business the first is a violation that the board had deferred disposition of to review submitted video evidence the lcy is Jan hung Inc doing business as new moon Villa Restaurant at 15 to 19 Edinboro Street date of this incident was October 27th 2023 assault and battery with a dangerous weapon Patron on Patron in violation of masteral laws chapter 138 section 64 and chap 265 section 15a I did have an opportunity to review the video um based upon what I saw in the video I don't think this assault and battery was foreseeable so I don't see a violation I agree it um you know maybe didn't happen so suddenly but suddenly enough it didn't like go on and on um the one thing I'll bring up is you know at this time in night I do question the adequacy of you know security um the staff's ability to kind of physically intervene in this yeah was lacking and just concerning um I wouldn't find a violation for it but you know after seeing it and now being aware of kind of the lay of the land at this time of night um I I feel like we should say something and put them on notice and question whether they need to up their security game very good point I agree all said CH car would you like that in correspondence from the board would you like it noted on the docket sheet how how would you like this to appear um definitely correspondence and maybe a request for them to get back to us with what their plan is going to be and you know the why like if they're not going to employ uh more physically capable security why can't they do that that kind of stuff and then um yeah the same same noted on the doc so not that um although unforeseeable U security may have been lacking in hindsight something like that would you like to request a formal like late night security plan from the lcy is that something I think we should yeah okay all right so no violation it will be noted on the doet Treet that the board found uh security um had concerns about security at this time of night correspondence from the board and a request for a formal late night security plan from the line yeah may I ask actually bring up it's happened a long time ago but I do recall even though they weren't written up for it there were allegations that the police were locked out for a short period of time so maybe another reiteration of you know their duty to cooperate with police cooperation and also it seemed pretty clear from the video they were serving beer hour that too I didn't know if we were going to get there but yeah they weren't written up for it it wasn't the um most egregious thing in the video I think the fight was so I wanted to focus agree with you focus on the security and um the other issues but I think if we're going to send correspondence we should note that it was clear in the video there was serving alcohol absolutely just to not that we saw it we didn't miss it yeah right that can be included as well thank you item number two uh is the the board have deferred this application to allow for completion of the community process which has since occurred the applicant Robert A caparella to 11 Handover Street uh had applied for a common vict 7-Day wines and M beverages with Lor's license Robert a caparella manager Closing Time 1:00 a.m indoors 12:00 a.m. Outdoors the applicant did present to both nunik and newa received support from nck and non- opposition from newa I believe Mr caparella has the appropriate character and fitness to serve as manager record and my vote would be to approve this um wial and lur license um pending the availability of one for which they qualify I agree I agree and just for the record what what was the community process did they what did they say what did the community say yep exactly so they there is a support letter from new Nick the North End Waterfront neighborhood Council and a non- opposition letter from new ra the North and Waterfront residents Association it thank you m and then item number three similarly the board had deferred the following to allow for the completion of the community process which also has since occurred kunan Gourmet LLC doing business as kunan Gourmet located at 45 Beach Street applied for a 7day wines and Mal beverages common pict of 7-Day wines and M beverages license she Chow Chang manager of record Closing Time 10:30 p.m. uh similarly they presented to three different resident groups within Chinatown received no opposition and um last night through a staffer we found out that they received support from councelor Flynn who was the district city councelor as well my vote is to approve pending the availability of one for which they qualify and to also approve the manager of record I agree I agree thank you all those are all of the items before the board today that will adjourn this morning's hearing so thank you and please do enjoy the rest of day thank you thank you