Brookline Select Board Addresses Middle East Resolution
-
Meeting Type:
City Council
-
Meeting Date:
03/12/2024
-
Recording Published:
03/12/2024
-
Duration:
256 Minutes
-
State:
Massachusetts
-
County:
Norfolk County
-
Towns:
Brookline
- Meeting Overview:
In a recent meeting of the Brookline Select Board, the most prominent and heated discussion revolved around Warrant Article 19, which concerns the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. The article proposed a resolution for a ceasefire and raised deep concerns among community members about its potential divisiveness and the accuracy of its portrayal of the situation. Residents voiced strong opinions both in favor and against the resolution. Supporters of the resolution argued for the town to take a stand for humanitarian reasons, while opponents criticized the resolution as unnecessary and possibly harmful to community cohesion. The debate underscored the complexities of addressing international conflicts at the local government level and highlighted the emotional nature of the topic.
During the public comments section, several residents spoke about Warrant Article 19. Arguments against the article cited concerns that it read like propaganda and could generate animosity and conflict within the community. Criticisms were made about the sourcing from other resolutions and a claim that the article contained factual inaccuracies. Conversely, other residents argued for the importance of taking a stand, with historical examples cited to underscore past resolutions on issues. The discussion also included a resident who offered an amendment they felt better represented the views of the majority of Brookline residents, without being politically leveraged by outside organizations.
The discourse on Article 19 also extended to its potential to increase anti-Semitism in the community, with some residents advocating for an amendment that supports peace efforts by qualified officials rather than debating foreign policy at a town meeting. Others emphasized the humanitarian crisis and argued for the town’s involvement. A speaker with a personal connection to the issue disagreed with the town government weighing in on foreign policy. In contrast, another resident argued that the town’s use of taxpayer dollars to fund the conflict made it a local issue, thus warranting discussion and action.
A member of the Select Board presented a proposal to shift contributions to the Other Post Employment Benefit liabilities and the stabilization fund in the fiscal year 2025 financial plan, highlighting the potential impact on the town’s credit rating and the need to maintain a AAA rating. The proposal included adding $750,000 to the OPEB liabilities and $500,000 to the stabilization fund, and was met with appreciation from some members for the effort and importance of maintaining the town’s bond rating.
The discussion of Article 15, which seeks to change the election of constables from a simultaneous election of all five constables every three years to a staggered model, was another significant item on the agenda. The proposed change aims to increase voter awareness of the constables’ role and provide more opportunities for individuals to run for townwide office. The public hearing for this article included comments from town meeting members and constables, expressing support for the proposed change. Concerns were also raised about the potential cost implications of staggered terms on constable bonds.
Article 16 was addressed, aiming to amend the bylaws to reduce the number of members on the Commission for Diversity, Equity, Inclusion, and Community Relations from 15 to 9. The amendment was supported by those who cited the challenges in filling all 15 seats and the impact on the commission’s functionality. The current chair of the commission voiced support for the proposed change, emphasizing the potential benefits in terms of reaching quorum and member participation.
The meeting delved into various operational matters of the town, including the approval of a Second Amendment to the lease with Temple Ohabei Shalom, which raised questions about operating expenses and the use of Capital funds. The Town Clerk’s budget presentation highlighted improvements in digitization and voter access, with goals for FY25 including expanding early voting and completing digitization projects. The HR and benefits presentation focused on classification, compensation, and employee training and development, providing updated demographic information on the town’s employee population.
The Department of Diversity, Equity, Inclusion, and Community Relations presented their budget, noting a professional services budget increase for language access needs and a decrease in the special program supply budget. Goals for the upcoming year included finalizing the townwide ADA transition plan and increasing voter participation in local government. The board discussed the potential impact of various trust funds, including the Health Trust Fund, the unemployment compensation trust fund, and the workers comp trust fund, on the town’s finances.
Charles Carey
City Council Officials:
Bernard Greene, John VanScoyoc, Miriam Aschkenasy, Michael Sandman, Paul Warren
-
Meeting Type:
City Council
-
Meeting Date:
03/12/2024
-
Recording Published:
03/12/2024
-
Duration:
256 Minutes
-
Notability Score:
Highly Noteworthy
Receive debriefs about local meetings in your inbox weekly:
-
State:
Massachusetts
-
County:
Norfolk County
-
Towns:
Brookline
Recent Meetings Nearby:
- 09/18/2024
- 09/18/2024
- 31 Minutes
- 09/18/2024
- 09/19/2024
- 86 Minutes
- 09/18/2024
- 09/18/2024
- 45 Minutes