Chatham Commission Navigates Historic Preservation and Modernization

The Chatham Historical Commission’s meeting on April 16, 2024, saw discussions on decisions regarding the preservation and modernization of historic properties were deliberated. Two properties, in particular, were the focus of discussion: the Elisha Burr House on Old Harbor Road and the Barzilla Hardy house on Water Street, both renowned for their historical significance.

At the meeting, the commission reviewed and approved renovation applications for these properties, balancing the need for preservation with modern practicalities. The Elisha Burr House received unanimous approval for restoration and construction work, including a clarification regarding a previously approved demolition of a barn on the property, which had lapsed. Meanwhile, the Barzilla Hardy house proposal, which included expanding the roof height of the rear L, renovating windows, and adding an addition to the easterly side, brought forth a spectrum of opinions from commission members and the public.

The presentation for the Barzilla Hardy house was met with both appreciation and concern. While some commission members lauded the attention to detail in replicating the existing structure within the new addition, others raised issues regarding the scale and potential impact of the changes. The conversation evolved into a broader debate on how to best maintain the historical integrity of such homes while accommodating necessary updates. Concerns were particularly voiced about the new addition potentially compromising the house’s historical essence.

The second property discussed was the historic home on Water Street, situated in The Old Village’s national registered district. The property owner’s representative provided an overview of the proposed work, which sparked debate among commission members. The focal point of contention was the potential impact of expanding and altering historic homes on their unique charm. One commission member expressed apprehensions about the loss of such charm due to expansions, while another praised the well-illustrated application, confident that the proposed alterations would not negatively affect the street view. After the debate, the commission passed several motions, determining that the proposed alterations and additions would not substantially alter the contributing structure within the National Historic Register District.

In addition to the property discussions, the commission also touched upon a variety of other pertinent topics. The meeting covered the progress of the Coast Guard boathouse restoration and addressed concerns about demolition by neglect, a recurring issue in historical preservation. The commission also discussed the upcoming preservation awards and the status of demolition delays.

Another topic of interest was the trial concerning the future of the Monomoy Theatre property. The case’s outcome has the potential to determine whether the applicant will be granted permission to build new houses or, alternatively, restore the theater. The outcome of this trial is of particular importance as it could set a precedent for how the commission handles similar cases in the future and highlights the ongoing tension between development and preservation in historic districts.

Note: This meeting summary was generated by AI, which can occasionally misspell names, misattribute actions, and state inaccuracies. This summary is intended to be a starting point and you should review the meeting record linked above before acting on anything you read. If we got something wrong, let us know. We’re working every day to improve our process in pursuit of universal local government transparency.
Town Manager:
Jill R. Goldsmith
Historic Preservation Commission Officials:
Frank Messina, Robert Lear, Steve Burlingame, Donald Aikman, Stephanie Hamilton, Janet Toenniessen, Sandi Porter, Robert Stevens, Dean P. Nicastro (Select Board Liaison), Christina Bassett (Staff Liaison)

Receive debriefs about local meetings in your inbox weekly:

Trending meetings
across the country:

Meeting Date
Filter by bodytypes
Agricultural Advisory Committee
Airport Advisory Board
Art and Culture Board
Beach Committee
Bike and Pedestrian Advisory Committee
Board of Elections
Board of Health
Borough Council
Building Committee
Cannabis Control Board
Cemetery Commission
Charter Revision Commission
Child and Family Services Board
City Council
City Identity Committee
Code Enforcement Board
College Board of Trustees
Community Appearance Board
Community Preservation Committee
Community Redevelopment Agency
County Council
Disability Advisory Committee
Economic Development Board
Elderly Affairs Board
Electric Advisory Board
Environmental Commission
Financial Oversight Board
Historic Preservation Commission
Housing Authority
Human Relations Committee
Human Resources Committee
Insurance Fund
Land Use Board
Library Board
Licensing Board
Mental Health Commission
Municipal Alliance
Open Space Commission
Oversight and Review Committee
Parent Advisory Board
Parking Authority
Parks and Gardens Commission
Parks Commission
Pension Board
Planning Board
Police Review Board
Port Authority
Property Assessment Board
Public Safety Committee
Recreation Commission
Redevelopment Agency
Rent Control Board
Rent Leveling Board
School Board
Sewerage Authority
Shade Tree Commission
Special Magistrate
Taxation & Revenue Advisory Committee
Tourism Board
Trails Committee
Transportation Board
Utility Board
Value Adjustment Board
Veterans Committee
Water Control Board
Women's Advisory Committee
Youth Advisory Committee
Zoning Board
Filter by County
FL
Bay County
Bradford County
Brevard County
Broward County
Clay County
Duval County
Escambia County
Gulf County
Hendry County
Highlands County
Hillsborough County
Indian River County
Lake County
Lee County
Leon County
Levy County
Liberty County
Manatee County
Marion County
Martin County
Miami-Dade County
Monroe County
Okaloosa County
Orange County
Osceola County
Palm Beach County
Pasco County
Pinellas County
Polk County
Putnam County
Santa Rosa County
Sarasota County
Seminole County
St. Johns County
Taylor County
Volusia County
Walton County
MA
Barnstable County
Berkshire County
Bristol County
Essex County
Franklin County
Hampden County
Hampshire County
Middlesex County
Norfolk County
Plymouth County
Suffolk County
Worcester County
MN
Anoka County
Becker County
Beltrami County
Benton County
Blue Earth County
Brown County
Carver County
Cass County
Chippewa County
Chisago County
Clay County
Cook County
Crow Wing County
Dakota County
Freeborn County
Goodhue County
Grant County
Hennepin County
Isanti County
Itasca County
Kanabec County
Kandiyohi County
Koochiching County
Lac Qui Parle County
Lyon County
Mcleod County
Morrison County
Mower County
Nicollet County
Olmsted County
Pipestone County
Polk County
Ramsey County
Rice County
Scott County
Sherburne County
Sibley County
St Louis County
Stearns County
Steele County
Waseca County
Washington County
Wright County
NJ
Atlantic County
Bergen County
Burlington County
Camden County
Cape May County
Cumberland County
Essex County
Gloucester County
Hudson County
Hunterdon County
Mercer County
Middlesex County
Monmouth County
Morris County
Ocean County
Passaic County
Somerset County
Sussex County
Union County
Warren County
NY
Bronx County
Kings County
New York County
Queens County
Richmond County
TN
Shelby County
Filter by sourcetypes
Minutes
Recording