One of the most engaging discussions centered around the historical paint colors for Bicentennial Hall. The commission is considering restoring the building to its original color, a specific shade of green, but there was no consensus on whether this would satisfy current aesthetic preferences. The conversation revealed differing opinions about the color’s historical importance versus contemporary tastes. To address this issue, the commission is deliberating on forming a committee composed of members from both the commission and the local association. This group would be tasked with reviewing potential colors and providing recommendations within 60 days, possibly with professional guidance. The need to include community members with personal connections to the building was emphasized, particularly those who might remember its past appearances.

In addition to paint color, the commission discussed the broader implications of maintaining historical integrity while meeting community needs. One member suggested considering the desires of the community alongside historical standards, emphasizing a balanced approach that avoids divisive decisions. The timeline for the repainting was addressed, highlighting the need to coordinate with ongoing construction efforts and ensure the building’s structural issues are resolved first.

Another major topic was the preservation and promotion of Fisk Chapel’s historical significance, particularly its importance to the African-American community in Fair Haven. It was suggested that a comprehensive communications strategy be developed to enhance public understanding of the chapel’s history. This endeavor would include creating a historical timeline, updating pamphlets, and developing digital resources to convey the chapel’s story effectively. The possibility of organizing a formal rededication ceremony once the chapel’s rehabilitation is complete was also proposed to further highlight its historical importance.

The commission acknowledged the need for collaboration with the Fair Haven Historic Association and other stakeholders to implement these educational initiatives. The conversation underscored the importance of involving younger residents and newcomers in these efforts, as many are unaware of the chapel’s history. A participant noted the potential for integrating technology and digital resources into the educational strategy, possibly by utilizing electronic displays or incorporating the chapel into broader narratives of African-American history, such as the Black Heritage Trail.

Community engagement was a recurring theme throughout the meeting, with discussions about the significance of involving local residents in historical preservation efforts. Members stressed the importance of collecting firsthand narratives from descendants of those who attended Fisk Chapel and the associated school. It was noted that social media could play a vital role in sharing historical snippets and engaging the public in the narrative-building process.

The meeting also broached the topic of preserving artifacts, such as the transom from the police department building, which dates back to its original use as a school. There was a dialogue about potential locations for the transom’s display, with suggestions ranging from the new community center to its original site at the police station. The preservation of lamp posts associated with the police station was also discussed, highlighting the challenges of incorporating these historical elements into new structures due to size constraints.

Lastly, the meeting briefly touched upon the upcoming joint celebration between Rumson and Fair Haven for the 250th anniversary of the Declaration of Independence. The commission expressed a commitment to participate in the festivities, with brainstorming underway for events that reflect local heritage. This celebration, dubbed the “semiquincentennial,” aims to engage various community groups and ensure a cohesive and inclusive celebration.