River Edge Board Examines Security Fence Proposal Amid Mixed Reactions Over Aesthetics and Safety
- Meeting Overview:
During the latest River Edge Land Use Board meeting, a proposed six-foot security fence surrounding a school sparked discussions about balancing security needs with aesthetic concerns. The application, submitted by a religious institution, raised both apprehension and support among board members and community participants. The board’s deliberations revealed a spectrum of opinions on the effectiveness and impact of the proposed fencing solution.
1:37:33The focal point of the meeting was the proposal for a six-foot security fence around a school property. The board grappled with the challenge of providing enhanced security while preserving the town’s aesthetic integrity. A board member articulated concerns about the stark appearance of the fence, describing it as potentially “unattractive.” This was a sentiment shared by others who worried about the impact on the town’s visual appeal.
36:19Security concerns were particularly pronounced given the school’s unique demographic and recent societal issues. The board highlighted the necessity of heightened security measures, acknowledging the specific vulnerabilities faced by the institution. In light of these considerations, the proposal included plans for a black aluminum fence, which was intended to serve as a deterrent to potential threats. However, the effectiveness of such a barrier was questioned by some board members and public commenters. One participant, with extensive experience in security, emphasized the deterrent value of a six-foot fence compared to a four-foot alternative, noting that the taller structure could discourage unauthorized access.
51:02Concerns about the fence’s visual impact were addressed through discussions about landscaping and design modifications. Participants suggested integrating street trees and exploring alternative colors or materials to soften the fence’s appearance. The conversation revealed a consensus on the importance of aesthetics in town planning, with some advocating for a balance between security measures and visual considerations. The idea of setting the fence further back from the road to allow for additional landscaping was deliberated, though practical concerns regarding terrain and visibility were acknowledged.
36:19In addition to aesthetic considerations, the board examined the practical implications of the fence. Questions were raised about the fence’s impact on traffic flow and pedestrian safety, with particular attention to the sight distance at intersections. The board explored the idea of engaging with county planners to address these concerns and ensure compliance with safety regulations. The proposal also included technical details about gate operations and security systems, which were intended to facilitate secure access for emergency personnel and visitors.
51:02Participants highlighted the necessity of a collaborative approach, involving input from security experts, planners, and community members to achieve a solution that meets multiple objectives.
1:37:33The board ultimately decided to carry the application over to the next meeting, allowing the applicants time to address the concerns raised. The next meeting, scheduled for March 12, will provide an opportunity for further deliberation and the presentation of additional information, including high-quality renderings to aid in decision-making.
As the meeting concluded, there was a reminder of the upcoming transition back to in-person meetings, expected to occur around late March or early April. This change will require adjustments in board operations and planning.
Thomas Papaleo
Land Use Board Officials:
Chris Caslin (Member – Chairman), Richard Mehrman (Member – Vice Chairman), Eileen Boland (Member), Dario Chinigo (Member), Ryan Gibbons (Member – Secretary), Michael Krey (Member), Bruce Feffer (Member), Colin Busteed (Alternate #2), Tom Behrens (Borough Planner), Robert Costa (Engineer), Stephen Depken (Land Use Zoning Officer), Marina Stinely (Land Use Attorney), Ed Alter (Land Use Clerk)
-
Meeting Type:
Land Use Board
-
Committee:
-
Meeting Date:
-
Recording Published:
02/14/2025
-
Duration:
115 Minutes
-
Notability Score:
Routine
Receive debriefs about local meetings in your inbox weekly:
-
State:
New Jersey
-
County:
Bergen County
-
Towns:
River Edge
Recent Meetings Nearby:
- 04/21/2025
- 04/21/2025
- 78 Minutes
- 04/21/2025
- 04/21/2025
- 26 Minutes
- 04/21/2025
- 04/22/2025
- 24 Minutes