Pleasantville School Board Faces Teacher Union Grievances and Troubling Student Proficiency Data

The Pleasantville School Board meeting on March 11, 2025, was marked by discussions on unresolved teacher grievances, concerning student proficiency in literacy and mathematics, and the introduction of a new board member. The meeting addressed ongoing issues related to faculty compensation, student performance, and infrastructure improvements within the district.

0:28The meeting began with public comments from Kathy Watson, president of the teachers union representing approximately 600 educators in the district. Watson highlighted grievances submitted on February 28, which had yet to receive a response from the superintendent. She raised concerns about the handling of employee placement on the salary guide by the human resources department, noting that the current system failed to recognize credits earned by employees. Watson argued that contractual language regarding tuition reimbursement was being misinterpreted, resulting in many staff members being denied salary guide advancement. She urged the board to ensure that all educators receive credit for college courses beyond their bachelor’s degrees, even if unrelated to their teaching content area. Watson emphasized the necessity of supporting the grievance process as it progresses, seeking fair compensation for the district’s teachers.

27:35In a related segment, the board discussed student proficiency data, revealing significant challenges in mathematics and literacy. Mr. Zachar Riot, the district’s supervisor of math and science, presented statistics indicating that proficiency ratings across various grades were notably low. In elementary grades three through five, only 14% of third graders, 22% of fourth graders, and 12% of fifth graders achieved proficiency in mathematics. The situation worsened in middle school, with proficiency rates dropping to 5% in sixth grade, 12% in seventh, and again 5% in eighth grade, highlighting a consistent struggle with mathematical concepts.

The scenario was equally concerning at the high school level, where a majority of ninth graders struggled with math proficiency, with only 13% meeting expectations. The New Jersey graduation proficiency assessment for 11th graders revealed that a mere 9% were considered ready for graduation. The board discussed implementing intervention strategies to address these challenges, including offering free tutoring and increasing resources for hands-on learning.

0:28In addition to academic performance, the condition of athletic facilities was brought to the board’s attention by a community member, Mrs. Priscilla Noel, who implored the board to focus on necessary repairs and improvements. She emphasized the need for equitable facilities compared to neighboring schools, presenting evidence of disrepair and urging the board to prioritize student safety and facility quality. In response, Dr. Marilyn Martinez, the superintendent, acknowledged these concerns and referenced a forthcoming budget proposal aimed at addressing the needed upgrades.

The meeting also celebrated achievements within the district. Dr. Martinez highlighted recent events honoring Black History Month and a senior student, Dyan Weber, who received a $25,000 scholarship from Chick-fil-A. Additionally, an increase in students receiving the New Jersey state seal of biliteracy was noted, with 56 students achieving this honor.

44:47Another notable event during the meeting was the acceptance of Mrs. Maria Pepy as the ninth School Board member. Pepy’s appointment was unanimously approved, and board members expressed their enthusiasm and congratulations. Following her introduction, the board moved to approve the superintendent’s report and various logistical items, including financial and facilities matters, without objection.

The meeting concluded with public comments from board members, who expressed gratitude to attendees and highlighted ongoing initiatives, such as the work of the Food Service committee and an upcoming wellness event. The meeting adjourned with a reminder of a special meeting scheduled to discuss the budget.

Note: This meeting summary was generated by AI, which can occasionally misspell names, misattribute actions, and state inaccuracies. This summary is intended to be a starting point and you should review the meeting record linked above before acting on anything you read. If we got something wrong, let us know. We’re working every day to improve our process in pursuit of universal local government transparency.

Receive debriefs about local meetings in your inbox weekly: