Biscayne Park Code Compliance Board Approves Lien Reductions Amid Property Violation Deliberations
- Meeting Overview:
The Biscayne Park Code Compliance Board meeting focused on resolving complex property violation cases, notably granting a significant lien reduction for a property on Northeast 111th Street. This decision came amidst discussions about permit compliance, fee clarifications, and ordinance interpretations.
0:11The most prominent topic of the meeting centered around the property on Northeast 111th Street, owned by Brett Anthony Frey. The property was entangled in multiple violations, leading to substantial liens. Represented by his brother Matthew Frey, who participated via Zoom, the owner sought a reduction in these liens, citing his severe health issues and financial struggles exacerbated by the pandemic. The board was presented with a contract of sale for the property.
The discussion revealed that the liens dated back to 2015 and 2021, with some records showing duplicated fines for similar violations. Matthew Frey detailed the financial burden these liens imposed on his brother, emphasizing the mental and physical toll it had taken. The board debated a $2,000 settlement offer for each of the seven cases, totaling $14,000, contingent on the property sale closing by April 10. Acknowledging the historical context, the board agreed to the reduction, with the provision that fines revert to their original amounts if the conditions were not met by the deadline. Additionally, a new case concerning exterior wall violations was dismissed, further easing the path for the property’s sale.
26:49In another discussion, the board tackled a case involving a $10,000 fee attached to a property under scrutiny. The attorney representing the mortgage servicer expressed frustration over the lack of detailed documentation regarding the fee’s breakdown. Despite the absence of precise records, a building official testified about the considerable work performed, defending the fee’s legitimacy. The board approved a motion to forward $1,000 in applicable fees.
Subsequent debates included fine reductions for properties with accumulated violations, despite ownership changes. A particularly notable case involved a property demolished and left compliant, yet burdened by fines totaling approximately $341,000. The new owner, having purchased the property at auction, was held responsible for these pre-existing violations. An offer of $500 per case to resolve the liens was deemed too low, prompting further negotiation and illustrating the complexities of managing compliance for properties with historical violations.
52:23Discussions about unauthorized work and permit compliance were also central to the meeting. A case involving a roofing permit violation on Northeast 113th Street highlighted issues of unauthorized work exceeding original plans and the use of a fake stamp, leading to a police investigation. The board clarified that the homeowner would not be held liable for the contractor’s actions, although a stop order was placed on the project.
1:14:09This issue was particularly evident in cases where permits were used as a delay tactic, leaving properties in a state of non-compliance. The board emphasized the necessity of not only applying for but also obtaining and fulfilling permit requirements to achieve compliance.
2:01:02The meeting concluded with discussions on the need to clarify ordinance language, especially concerning construction and noise violations. The board recognized the ambiguities present in the current codes and expressed intent to address these with the Village manager and attorney.
Jonathan E. Groth
Code Enforcement Board Officials:
Janey Anderson (Chair), Rodolfo Barrientos, Dale Blanton, Judi Hamelburg, Michael Lynott, Esq., Ashlin Bernier-Green (Alternate)
-
Meeting Type:
Code Enforcement Board
-
Committee:
-
Meeting Date:
03/12/2025
-
Recording Published:
03/12/2025
-
Duration:
144 Minutes
-
Notability Score:
Routine
Receive debriefs about local meetings in your inbox weekly:
-
State:
Florida
-
County:
Miami-Dade County
-
Towns:
Biscayne Park
Recent Meetings Nearby:
- 03/13/2025
- 03/13/2025
- 91 Minutes
- 03/13/2025
- 03/13/2025
- 69 Minutes
- 03/13/2025
- 03/13/2025
- 29 Minutes