Amherst Town Council Discusses Town-School Collaboration and Voting Process Challenges
- Meeting Overview:
The Amherst Town Council meeting focused on the issues of collaboration between the town council and the school committee, alongside challenges in the council’s voting processes. The council explored ways to improve transparency and communication while also addressing the complexities of categorizing and interpreting votes.
A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to the strained relationship between the town council and the school committee, which was highlighted as a concern by community members. Concerns were raised regarding the lack of effective communication and collaboration between the two bodies, emphasizing the need for consultation and a examination of community feedback. The sentiment was that the community would be disappointed if these issues were not addressed, especially in terms of school funding and its implications for educators. One council member remarked that this was “at least one of the top three issues facing this community,” underscoring its importance.
The council considered seeking advice from the Collins Center on how to frame the issue in a way that reflects community concerns without being overly emotional. There was debate on whether the relationship was a structural issue or one of interpersonal dynamics. Some believed systemic changes were necessary, while others argued that the issue was more about people within the existing framework. Eventually, members agreed on the need to frame the issue as a “desire for greater quality communication” rather than a “lack of collaboration.”
In discussing the council’s voting processes, members grappled with the implications of abstentions and flagged votes, which had led to confusion regarding majority decisions. There was a push for clarity in the voting system, with a focus on ensuring that abstentions were not misinterpreted as votes for or against proposals. The council also debated whether some flagged items required further discussion or could be recorded without recommendations for changes.
A proposal to reduce the lame duck period from eight weeks to three weeks was flagged for needing more information. The council also discussed the feasibility of including a recall provision in the charter, which had received mixed responses.
One member advocated for focusing on items that lacked clear consensus. This approach was seen as a way to clarify positions and ensure efficient progress. The council also considered the importance of public outreach about existing capabilities and the need to prioritize translation services for the town’s diverse population.
The council faced challenges in achieving a majority when not all members were present, leading to discussions about the feasibility of tracking individual votes for transparency. There was a motion to send the finalized green list to Collins for feedback, which received unanimous support.
To address the complexities of the voting process and ensure inclusivity, the council considered forming a writing committee to facilitate the drafting of a report. The timing of feedback from Collins was uncertain, prompting a proposal to send a preliminary document to Collins to prompt a partial response. The council agreed to create a Google document to consolidate feedback and suggestions, with a request for a meeting with Collins to discuss timelines and capacity for feedback.
Paul Brockelman
City Council Officials:
Mandi Jo Hanneke, Andrew J. Steinberg, Ellisha Walker, Ndifreke Ette, Cathy A. Schoen, Patricia C. De Angelis, Lynn Griesemer, Hala Heather A. Lord, George Ryan, Pamela Rooney, Jennifer Taub, Ana Devlin-Gauthier, Robert Hegner, Athena O’Keeffe (Clerk of the Council)
-
Meeting Type:
City Council
-
Committee:
-
Meeting Date:
09/18/2025
-
Recording Published:
09/19/2025
-
Duration:
123 Minutes
-
Notability Score:
Routine
Receive debriefs about local meetings in your inbox weekly:
-
State:
Massachusetts
-
County:
Hampshire County
-
Towns:
Amherst
Recent Meetings Nearby:
- 12/06/2025
- 12/06/2025
- 50 Minutes
- 12/06/2025
- 12/06/2025
- 115 Minutes