At the center of the commission’s recent meeting was a proposal by architect Michael Monroe for the restoration of a historic structure located on River Road in Fair Haven’s historic commercial district. Monroe detailed the challenges faced due to the building’s age, including uneven flooring and outdated construction that fails to meet current safety codes. The proposed restoration aims to preserve the building’s historical integrity while modernizing its functionality. This includes plans to redo the siding with five-inch hardy board and AAC trim, restore existing shutters with black wrought iron hardware, and rebuild the chimney with a wooden core and brick exterior.

Monroe emphasized the importance of maintaining the building’s historical character, particularly in relation to the front porch. The commission members expressed a preference for using traditional materials such as hardwoods like mahogany or fir, rather than composites, to ensure the porch’s authenticity and longevity. The discussion also touched on the landscaping plan and the visibility of new signage.

The project faced scrutiny regarding the structural integrity of the columns, which were found to be in good condition and are likely to be refinished. However, the underlying structure required rebuilding of brick piers. Concerns were also raised about the Yankee gutter system, which would need addressing to ensure longevity. Additionally, a freestanding shed in the back, described as lacking historical significance and falling apart, is slated for demolition.

Following thorough deliberations, the commission approved the application, specifying the use of wood products with a 5-inch reveal for siding, retention of shutters and columns, rebuilding of the chimney, and materials for the front porch. The Yankee gutter system was to be maintained, and windows specified as SD 6 over six.

In other business, the commission discussed upcoming restoration efforts for Bicentennial Hall. The commission intends to have a say in these decisions before they are formalized by the council, with a workshop session scheduled to further discuss these matters.

The appointment of a liaison to represent the commission at an upcoming council meeting was also addressed. Steve Heller was nominated to attend a workshop featuring Laura Burwin, who is overseeing restoration concepts for historic properties. This meeting will focus on exterior paint selections, which could influence the overall restoration project.

The commission additionally considered potential landmark designations for a state funding initiative. The sites proposed for consideration included the Greenbook House, Shrewsbury River Yacht Club, and Browns Lane. While some members debated the historical significance of these sites, particularly Browns Lane and its association with descendants of freed slaves, there was agreement on the need to prioritize sites for the grant application.

The conversation highlighted the role of historical markers in educating the community about Fair Haven’s heritage. Members discussed the placement challenges of markers, especially on private properties, and the design of such signage. The significance of various historical figures and events, such as the impact of the ferry service and the subdivision of the McCarter Estate, was noted.

The meeting also covered updates on other properties, such as site stabilization efforts on Fairherry Road. The project is delayed due to a contractor’s availability, with a $500,000 county grant expected to support planning and community engagement. Ideas for fundraising initiatives, like a bench sponsorship program, were also floated.

Lastly, the commission explored the possibility of establishing a local historic preservation award program, inspired by a recent award given to Murphy’s Tavern in Rumson. Members expressed interest in recognizing property owners’ efforts outside designated historic districts, potentially integrating award presentations with existing community events.