A significant portion of the meeting was devoted to addressing the increasing deer population in Old Tappan and its surrounding areas. Representatives from the Animal Protection League presented an alternative view on managing deer numbers, challenging traditional hunting practices. Doris Lynn, the League’s legal director, provided a detailed presentation critiquing hunting as an ineffective method for controlling deer populations, emphasizing that it primarily serves recreational purposes rather than population management. Lynn argued that the current practices of the New Jersey Division of Fish and Wildlife inadvertently encourage deer population growth by maintaining habitats that favor deer proliferation.

Lynn highlighted the concept of “cultural carrying capacity,” suggesting that while the deer population might not exceed what ecosystems can sustain, it surpasses what communities are willing to tolerate. She pointed out that non-lethal methods, such as surgical sterilization, have been employed successfully in other regions and could serve as a viable alternative for Old Tappan, albeit at a higher cost. The presentation sparked a discussion among attendees, with some expressing concern over the financial implications of implementing such strategies. The council members acknowledged the need for a comprehensive approach to manage the deer population effectively while considering the community’s welfare and budget constraints.

The meeting also addressed the safety concerns surrounding Halloween celebrations, with a proposal to close certain roads to ensure the safety of trick-or-treaters in heavily trafficked neighborhoods. Residents Jen Griffin and Jordan Sheen presented the proposal, emphasizing the need to protect small children from potential accidents, especially with the rise of ebikes and scooters. The council deliberated on the timing of the road closures, considering the overlap with rush hour traffic and the need for emergency access.

The idea of creating a festive community atmosphere was discussed, with suggestions for a DJ and food options. However, some council members expressed reservations about setting a precedent for road closures, fearing it might lead to similar demands from other neighborhoods. The council agreed to consult with the police chief for further input before making a final decision. Residents shared their experiences with the growing number of trick-or-treaters from outside the community, raising concerns about safety and logistical challenges during the event.

In another development, the meeting addressed the vacancy left by the resignation of Councilwoman Christine Massaro. The council was tasked with appointing a replacement from three candidates selected by the county committee. Donna Costello was nominated and unanimously approved as the new council member, despite concerns about the lack of background information provided by the county committee. The mayor emphasized the urgency of the appointment, given the statutory timeline for filling the vacancy.

The council also discussed issues related to ebike safety, particularly in school zones. Residents reported reckless behavior from young ebike riders, prompting the council to consider drafting an ordinance to address these concerns. The proposed ordinance aims to enhance safety measures, with plans for a public meeting to inform residents about the potential regulations.

Amidst the primary discussions, the council provided updates on various community initiatives. The Department of Public Works announced plans for a paper shredding event, and the library is preparing for its upcoming craft fair. The recreation department mentioned ongoing efforts to address deer droppings on local soccer fields, while the fire department highlighted its fire safety awareness initiatives. Upcoming community events, including the town day and the superhero 5K, were also noted.