Islamorada Village Council Faces Community Divide Over Baseball Field Turf Decision
- Meeting Overview:
The Islamorada Village Council meeting was dominated by discussions about the future of the baseball field at Founders Park. The debate centered on whether to install artificial turf or maintain natural grass. Opinions were sharply divided, with strong advocacy from community members on both sides of the argument. Meanwhile, other matters addressed included the advancement of a baseball license agreement, community beautification efforts, and important budgetary considerations.
The ongoing debate about the surface of the Founders Park baseball field took precedence during the council meeting. Jamie Engel, involved with the baseball field task force, expressed concerns over the adoption of artificial turf, highlighting the need for a thorough community survey before finalizing any decisions. Engel emphasized the importance of a written agreement delineating responsibilities between the village and the school district, especially regarding taxpayer money. This sentiment was echoed by Alina Davis, another task force member, who urged for mutual agreement and highlighted concerns over unilateral decisions.
In contrast, local business owner Joseph Molinaro and Coral Shores High School baseball coach Joe Samansky advocated for artificial turf, citing the maintenance difficulties of natural grass and the safety benefits of turf. Samansky pointed out the impracticality of maintaining the current grass field, emphasizing the urgency of a decision to ensure player safety and field usability.
The council was presented with differing views, with task force member Tony Hammond arguing against conducting another survey, citing his extensive experience in baseball. Captain Ed Davidson raised concerns about the lack of transparency in the planning process and emphasized the need for clarity in the baseball field license agreement.
The council also navigated discussions on the preliminary design plan for the baseball field, which had been approved by the Monroe County School Board. Concerns were raised about the decision-making process and the importance of community involvement and transparency regarding the type of turf and the design of facilities like the concession stand. The projected timeline for breaking ground was set for May 2026, after the upcoming baseball season. The council underscored the necessity of a robust interlocal agreement to ensure quality standards for the artificial turf.
In addition to the baseball field deliberations, the council addressed several other matters. During the meeting, the council explored community beautification initiatives, notably the landscaping improvements spearheaded by the Venetian Shores Homeowners Association. The association successfully raised significant funds to enhance the neighborhood, and their efforts were lauded as a model for community engagement.
Another focal point was the procurement of emergency services equipment. The council discussed the acquisition of a new ambulance and a fireboat, highlighting the importance of maintaining operational readiness, especially during peak tourist seasons. The fire department plans to remount an existing ambulance box onto a new chassis, emphasizing the cost-effectiveness and necessity of having a reserve ambulance during high-traffic periods.
The council also tackled budgetary issues, particularly concerning wastewater management. With a consent order initiating a 60-day timeframe for the village to present its plan, a special meeting was scheduled to address all wastewater-related matters. The council engaged in discussions about budget amendments and the procurement of emergency services equipment. They also explored ways to reduce costs associated with accessing public records, expressing enthusiasm about not charging the public exorbitant fees for email access.
As the meeting progressed, the council focused on resolving ongoing construction delays and issues related to recent projects. Discussions centered around a generator storage building project, with council members expressing concern over the project’s management and the appearance of the site. The council emphasized the importance of accountability and timely execution, proposing penalties for failing to meet project deadlines.
Sharon Mahoney
City Council Officials:
Don Horton (Vice Mayor), Joseph “Buddy” Pinder III, Deb Gillis, Steve Friedman
-
Meeting Type:
City Council
-
Committee:
-
Meeting Date:
11/10/2025
-
Recording Published:
11/12/2025
-
Duration:
288 Minutes
-
Notability Score:
Routine
Receive debriefs about local meetings in your inbox weekly:
-
State:
Florida
-
County:
Monroe County
-
Towns:
Islamorada
Recent Meetings Nearby:
- 12/04/2025
- 12/04/2025
- 51 Minutes
- 12/03/2025
- 12/03/2025
- 79 Minutes
- 12/03/2025
- 12/03/2025
- 127 Minutes