Proponents highlighted the importance of inclusivity and the need to protect all community members, regardless of their immigration status. One speaker argued that the resolution would promote behaviors of respect and dignity, aligning with the community’s values.

Conversely, opponents expressed concerns about the potential legal implications and perceived threats to community safety posed by the resolution. Some residents argued that the resolution could be seen as a step toward becoming a sanctuary city, a claim refuted by those in favor of the resolution. Critics also voiced fears about the impact on local law enforcement and questioned the board’s authority to address immigration issues, which they contended fall under federal jurisdiction. The debate was marked by emotional testimonies and personal anecdotes, with speakers referencing historical and contemporary issues to support their positions.

Ultimately, the Select Board voted against approving the resolution, with members citing concerns about its alignment with the board’s responsibilities and the potential for unintended consequences. A motion to present the resolution to town council for legal review was approved.

In a separate agenda item, the Select Board recognized the heroic actions of first responders during a trench collapse incident on November 18, 2025. The board issued official citations to various departments and individuals involved in the rescue efforts, including the Yarmouth Fire Department, the Department of Public Works, and neighboring towns that provided mutual aid. The chair emphasized the heroism displayed by those who risked their lives to save others.

The meeting also featured discussions on a proposed town-sponsored event to commemorate a new Revolutionary War monument. Organizers sought the board’s support to designate the event as a town-sponsored celebration, highlighting the potential for tourism and community engagement. The board approved the proposal and allocated funding to support the event, which aims to honor the town’s historical significance and attract visitors from beyond Cape Cod.

Additionally, the board addressed routine matters, including the transfer of liquor licenses and updates from the Cape Cod Collaborative. The collaborative, which provides educational services to member districts, presented its current initiatives and financial challenges, emphasizing the need for legislative advocacy to support capital planning efforts.