South Orange-Maplewood School Board Faces Budget Deficit, Tackles Racial Disparities, and Considers Ranked Choice Voting
- Meeting Overview:
The South Orange-Maplewood School Board meeting addressed issues including a budget shortfall, racial disparities in student achievement and discipline, and the potential adoption of ranked choice voting. The board discussed strategies to tackle these challenges, focusing on fiscal sustainability, equity in education, and electoral reform.
A substantial portion of the meeting was dedicated to addressing the projected budget shortfall for the 2026-27 fiscal year. The board discussed various strategies to mitigate the financial difficulties, emphasizing the need for strategic staffing decisions, adjustments to courtesy busing, and the repurposing of funds saved from a spending freeze implemented in November. The board stressed the importance of monitoring expenditures closely, including special education services, to ensure they are efficient and effective.
Superintendent Jason Bing highlighted the racial disparities in student performance and discipline, noting that while 85% of white students achieved arts proficiency, only 50% of Black students did. He reported that 20 out of 24 out-of-school suspensions were assigned to Black students. This stark disparity underscores the ongoing challenges in achieving equity within the educational system. Bing reflected on the potential of students and the responsibility of educational leaders to support their growth. He emphasized the importance of addressing these issues through collaborative efforts with community organizations, such as the Black Parents Workshop, although acknowledging that significant work remains to be done.
In line with efforts to address these disparities, outgoing board member Bill Gifford, celebrated for his dedication to equity and academic excellence, reiterated the importance of providing alternative pathways for students beyond traditional college routes. Gifford emphasized the need for vocational programs, like the recently reestablished woodshop classes, and the progress in implementing solar energy solutions within the district. However, he expressed disappointment over the stagnant progress in closing the racial achievement gap, noting disparities in graduation rates and standardized test scores between white and Black students.
The board also considered a resolution supporting ranked choice voting, which aims to enhance electoral processes by allowing voters to rank candidates by preference. Proponents of the resolution argued that ranked choice voting could promote community cohesion and reduce political polarization by encouraging candidates to appeal to a broader range of voters. Several community members, including teachers and local activists, voiced their support for the initiative during the public comment segment. The resolution seeks to gain support from the New Jersey School Boards Association for legislation that would permit municipalities and school boards to implement ranked choice voting.
During the meeting, several outgoing board members were honored for their service, with particular recognition given to their contributions in various areas of district governance. Regina Eckert, outgoing second vice president, was commended for her behind-the-scenes leadership, her role in advocating for teacher morale, and her efforts to update the student hardship transfer policy. The board acknowledged her critical thinking and oversight during the budget process.
Additionally, the board discussed the development of a new communications policy aimed at improving teacher-student interactions. The proposal seeks to enhance the educational experience by ensuring effective communication methods, emphasizing timely responses from teachers. This initiative was discussed alongside a new student administrative internship program, designed to provide meaningful real-world experiences for students while supporting school administrators.
The meeting included a presentation on the energy savings improvement plan, highlighting projects such as high-efficiency lighting and HVAC improvements to enhance environmental sustainability. Soil testing for the Ritzer field project was ongoing, with findings expected to inform the design of the planned drainage system. The board confirmed the completion of the district’s audit, noting the potential to repurpose unexpended balances from previous bond sales for early design work on the Ritzer field project.
The board also addressed public concerns, including staffing changes at Montrose and a recent anti-Semitic incident at Columbia High School. Community members expressed distress over the transfer of a valued staff member and questioned the urgency in reporting the anti-Semitic incident, highlighting a pattern of delayed reporting and inadequate compliance with state law and board policies on harassment and hate crimes.
Jason Bing
School Board Officials:
Nubia DuVall Wilson, William Meyer, Regina Eckert, Jeffrey Bennett, Deirdre Brown, Elizabeth Callahan, Bill Gifford, Bimal Kapadia, Shayna Sackett-Gable, Oliver Nesin, Asa Glassman, Dr. Kevin Gilbert (Asst., Supt., Access & Equity), Ms. Robin Curry (Confidential Secretary to the Asst. Supt., Access & Equity)
-
Meeting Type:
School Board
-
Committee:
-
Meeting Date:
12/18/2025
-
Recording Published:
12/18/2025
-
Duration:
250 Minutes
-
Notability Score:
Noteworthy
Receive debriefs about local meetings in your inbox weekly:
-
State:
New Jersey
-
County:
Essex County
-
Towns:
Maplewood, South Orange
Recent Meetings Nearby:
- 12/23/2025
- 12/23/2025
- 17 Minutes
- 12/23/2025
- 12/23/2025
- 25 Minutes
- 12/23/2025
- 12/23/2025
- 39 Minutes