Highland Park School Board Grapples with Low Math Scores and Curriculum Challenges
- Meeting Overview:
During the latest Highland Park School Board meeting, discussions were dominated by concerning trends in student math performance, particularly at the middle school level, and the district’s response through new curriculum pilots. The board focused on the stark decline in math scores, notably among middle school students, where only 7% to 20% met a 60% benchmark, a significant drop from the previous year’s 28% to 61%. Board members and community participants speculated on potential causes, including previous teacher turnover and a need for curriculum reassessment.
The board outlined plans for piloting four different math curricula—Clear Math, Into Math, Eureka, and Envision. Each curriculum will be tested in one class per grade level, beginning February 18 and concluding by spring break. The pilot aims to address foundational gaps in math understanding, with a focus on geometry or measurement units. Concerns were raised about the feasibility of running all pilots simultaneously and the potential strain on resources and professional development. This concern was echoed by a member of the public, Abby Stern Cardell, who emphasized the need for comprehensive data collection and the importance of not spreading resources too thinly. The estimated cost for the pilot is between $8,000 and $9,000, covering necessary materials and resources, with a rubric and program assessments set to evaluate the effectiveness of each curriculum.
The meeting also highlighted significant improvements in English Language Arts (ELA) performance, particularly in middle school, where scores rose to 56% to 69% at or above grade level, up from 41% to 46% the previous year. This progress was attributed to consistent professional development and curriculum investment. However, the board acknowledged that similar efforts had not been applied to math, calling for renewed focus on enhancing middle school math instruction.
In financial matters, the lead auditor presented the district’s financial highlights, noting an increase in overall revenues by approximately $883,000. However, federal special revenue saw a decline of about $390,000 due to the early sunset of ARP erates. Despite this, state aid for special revenue increased, notably for preschool programs, rising from $785,000 to $1.4 million. The district saw a decrease in operating expenditures by about one million dollars, with a significant reduction in pupil transportation costs. Questions arose regarding the anticipated increase in health benefit costs and the implications for the district, highlighting the need for ongoing fiscal responsibility.
Another focus was the district’s fund balance, which increased by $1.278 million. The capital reserve was bolstered to manage capital needs without relying heavily on taxpayers for bond issuance. The board discussed the importance of maintaining healthy reserves and the regulations governing excess surplus funds. A recommendation from the audit addressed the cafeteria fund’s outstanding balances, with Highland Park identified as proactive in managing this issue.
The board recognized the achievements of exemplary student Asenna Urkin, whose contributions to the school community were highlighted by Middle School Principal Caitlyn Brady. Testimonials from teachers praised Asenna’s academic excellence, leadership, and positive influence among peers, underscoring her role as a model student.
As the meeting progressed, board member Jennifer Voorhees was acknowledged for her service as she concluded her term. Her efforts in finance, facilities, and communication were commended, with board members emphasizing her contributions to improving communication and fostering a respectful atmosphere during discussions.
The meeting also addressed concerns about low participation rates in academic programs, with only 15 of 84 invited middle school students opting into additional ELA and math programs. Despite outreach efforts, such as multilingual communication and mailed notifications, engagement remained low. The board discussed potential factors, including after-school activities and social autonomy, and considered exploring successful practices from other districts to incentivize participation.
In administrative updates, the board reviewed personnel changes, including maternity leaves, resignations, and new appointments. The resignation of a middle school newspaper advisor and the appointment of a new orchestra director were noted. The board also discussed compensation adjustments for paraprofessionals and approved professional development opportunities for staff.
The meeting concluded with discussions on various educational and extracurricular initiatives, including a proposal for a Schedule B for a new K-pop club and updates on special education program evaluations. The board emphasized the importance of ongoing evaluation and adaptation of educational strategies to meet student needs effectively.
Kristina Susca
School Board Officials:
Allison Casal-Dunn, Ann Vardeman, Dr. Dan Battey, Dr. Monique Coleman, Nicole Longoria Stanio, Dr. Sara Pixley, Marilyn Pruce, Dr. Ethan Schoolman, Jennifer Voorhees, Seth Shapiro (Student Representative), Ana Juricic (Student Representative)
-
Meeting Type:
School Board
-
Committee:
-
Meeting Date:
12/22/2025
-
Recording Published:
12/23/2025
-
Duration:
122 Minutes
-
Notability Score:
Routine
Receive debriefs about local meetings in your inbox weekly:
-
State:
New Jersey
-
County:
Middlesex County
-
Towns:
Highland Park
Recent Meetings Nearby:
- 03/04/2026
- 03/04/2026
- 182 Minutes
- 03/04/2026
- 03/04/2026
- 45 Minutes