Shutesbury Select Board Tackles Open Meeting Law Complaints and Appoints New Police Chief
- Meeting Overview:
The Shutesbury Select Board meeting covered various topics, from addressing open meeting law complaints to appointing a new police chief. The board also reviewed fire department updates and discussed future community events, while navigating the intricacies of municipal operations and resident concerns.
A significant portion of the meeting focused on multiple open meeting law complaints, highlighting issues with email communications among board members. One notable incident involved a “reply all” email that violated open meeting laws, as acknowledged by the board. Eric expressed regret for the oversight, admitting that the volume of emails can make such mistakes easy to overlook. However, the issue sparked a tense exchange with a resident named Tom, who characterized the email as containing “unfounded and untrue claims” and sought clarification on its implications for public participation. Despite Tom’s insistence on discussing the email’s impact, the board opted not to engage further on this topic during the meeting, emphasizing their authority to set the agenda.
In an effort to address the violation, the board prepared to read the relevant emails aloud and include them in the meeting minutes, as directed by the Massachusetts Attorney General’s office. The emails detailed feelings of ostracism and retaliation, while board members expressed confusion over the communications. This acknowledgment set the stage for potential further discussions about maintaining transparency and ensuring fair treatment within the community.
In a separate but equally important decision, the board appointed Devin Pelletier as the new police chief, effective January 6, 2026. The appointment followed an extensive interview process that evaluated the qualifications of both candidates, Devin Pelletier and Ben Peters. The board expressed gratitude for Ben Peters’ participation and unanimously approved the motion to appoint Pelletier, emphasizing the qualifications that made him the ideal choice for the role.
The meeting also featured updates from the fire department. Chief Zwanka reported on the department’s activity, noting ten calls so far this year, including medical emergencies and an animal rescue. He highlighted the need to replace Engine Two, a vehicle from 1996, with costs for a new engine ranging from the low $700s to $950,000. The board discussed the merits of investing in a new truck versus repairing the old one, with Chief Zwanka emphasizing the necessity of a dump tank for operations.
Additionally, the board reviewed and approved a volunteer liability waiver policy and discussed a request from the Valley Players, a local community theater group, to use forest trails behind the library for a Shakespeare camp. The group received necessary approvals from town officials, and a safety plan was in place for the camp, which is set to run from June 22nd to July 2nd.
The town administrator provided updates on ongoing projects, including dam repairs and budget planning. Concerns were raised about the anticipated significant increase in the regional school budget, prompting ongoing discussions among the towns involved. Compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act by 2027 was also addressed, with the administrator attending a session about potential grants for necessary website changes.
The meeting concluded with discussions about the MN Spear Library’s porch, which is in urgent need of repair. The board endorsed a proposal to seek Community Preservation Act funding for the project, agreeing to draft a letter to formalize their support.
Rebecca Torres
City Council Officials:
Rita Farrell, Melissa Makepeace O’Neil, Eric Stocker
-
Meeting Type:
City Council
-
Committee:
-
Meeting Date:
02/03/2026
-
Recording Published:
02/04/2026
-
Duration:
51 Minutes
-
Notability Score:
Routine
Receive debriefs about local meetings in your inbox weekly:
-
State:
Massachusetts
-
County:
Franklin County
-
Towns:
Shutesbury
Recent Meetings Nearby:
- 03/12/2026
- 03/12/2026
- 22 Minutes
- 03/12/2026
- 03/13/2026
- 198 Minutes
- 03/12/2026
- 03/13/2026
- 79 Minutes