New Milford Borough Council Faces Resident Opposition Over Redevelopment Plans Amid Affordable Housing and Infrastructure Concerns.
- Meeting Overview:
The New Milford Borough Council meeting focused heavily on the redevelopment plans for the Brookchester Shopping Center, sparking community concern. The project proposes 150 residential units and 27,000 square feet of retail space, which raised questions about its impact on local infrastructure, housing balance, and schools. Residents expressed skepticism about the benefits, emphasizing potential negative effects on the community and local businesses.
The presentation by the Grenetti organization on the redevelopment of the Brookchester Shopping Center was the centerpiece of the meeting. The proposed plan involves transforming the outdated center into a mixed-use development featuring residential and commercial components, including approximately 150 residential units and 27,000 square feet of retail space. A fully operational CVS store would remain, but the total retail area would decrease from its current size. The redevelopment aims to modernize the area and address the costly maintenance of the existing strip mall, which has been described as past its useful life.
Residents voiced concerns over the project’s implications for affordable housing and local infrastructure. The development includes a mandate that 20% of the units, or 30 units, be designated for low to moderate-income households. However, the council and residents are wary of overdevelopment, fearing it could strain local schools, emergency services, and flood-prone infrastructure. The borough attorney mentioned ongoing litigation concerning these housing plans, hinting that not all questions could be answered due to potential legal repercussions.
Public reaction was mixed, with many residents opposing the redevelopment. One resident argued that the strip mall, which is fully leased and home to many small businesses, provides essential services and jobs in the community. The fear is that tearing it down would lead to job losses and economic instability. Another resident questioned the project’s effect on local schools, citing a lack of data on the potential influx of school-age children. The developer admitted that a formal study on school impact had not been conducted, which drew criticism.
The parking situation was another point of contention. The developer plans to provide 390 parking spaces, exceeding the state’s requirement, including 39 spaces for electric vehicles. Yet, many residents remain concerned about existing parking issues, exacerbated by the limited space and the flood-prone location of the proposed garage entrance. Suggestions for better pedestrian access and addressing current parking inadequacies were made, emphasizing the need for comprehensive planning.
Environmental and community impact assessments, which are typically part of the approval process, have not been completed, leading to frustration among residents. Concerns about flooding, particularly at the garage entrance from Dorchester Lane, were prevalent. Residents emphasized the necessity of addressing these issues before moving forward with new construction.
In addition to the redevelopment discussion, the council meeting included the adoption of several ordinances. These ordinances addressed various local issues, such as regulating electric vehicle parking and amending procedures for lead-based paint inspections in residential properties. Despite the routine nature of these ordinances, they drew little public attention during the meeting.
The meeting also highlighted upcoming community events, such as a pancake breakfast and an Easter egg hunt. An engineering update revealed ongoing and planned infrastructure improvements, although some projects were temporarily halted for winter.
Michael Putrino
City Council Officials:
Randi Duffie (Council President), Hedy Grant (Councilwoman), Ira Grotsky (Councilman), Lisa Sandhusen (Councilwoman), Matthew Seymour (Councilman), Art Zeilner (Councilman)
-
Meeting Type:
City Council
-
Committee:
-
Meeting Date:
03/23/2026
-
Recording Published:
03/24/2026
-
Duration:
95 Minutes
-
Notability Score:
Routine
Receive debriefs about local meetings in your inbox weekly:
-
State:
New Jersey
-
County:
Bergen County
-
Towns:
New Milford
Recent Meetings Nearby:
- 04/15/2026
- 04/15/2026
- 253 Minutes
- 04/15/2026
- 04/15/2026
- 35 Minutes
- 04/15/2026
- 04/16/2026
- 82 Minutes