Old Tappan Council Faces Controversy Over Rehabilitation Facility’s Residential Zoning
- Meeting Overview:
At the recent Old Tappan Borough Council meeting, issues surrounding a drug and alcohol rehabilitation facility on Bush Street took center stage. A resident voiced concerns about the facility, which reportedly houses 30 to 50 individuals in a residential area, raising questions about zoning, safety, and community impact. Additionally, the council discussed zoning ordinance amendments and collaborative police efforts, among other matters.
The meeting’s most contentious topic involved the rehabilitation facility located on Bush Street. A resident, Nick Safrager, expressed his dissatisfaction with the facility’s operation in a residential neighborhood, claiming it poses a threat to community safety due to its proximity to schools. Safrager highlighted that he was previously informed that the property was designated as a single-resident home, which contradicts the current usage as a group home for numerous individuals. He described behaviors he found suspicious, such as residents hastily entering the building, which led him to question the activities taking place there.
Legal complexities were discussed, particularly the definition of a family in the context of zoning laws. It was noted that precedent allows non-related individuals to be classified as a family if they share meals and communal living arrangements. However, the presence of potentially 30 individuals in a single-family home raised zoning concerns. The facility’s compliance with fire safety regulations and licensing requirements was questioned, as it reportedly had not passed necessary inspections. Safrager emphasized the need for intervention.
The council acknowledged that the borough’s zoning officer would need to investigate the matter further, including verifying the facility’s permits and the number of bedrooms available. There was a consensus that proper investigations should be conducted, with the involvement of the council’s land use counsel, who had experience with similar issues. The matter was left with assurances of follow-up actions to address the resident’s concerns.
In addition to the zoning controversy, the council adopted Ordinance Number 1291-26, which amends Chapter 255 regarding zoning and establishes town center overlay zones. This ordinance, introduced on February 17, 2026, was adopted on its second and final reading. The council also endorsed the fourth round of the housing element and fair share plan, which included a settlement establishing the borough’s affordable housing obligations. The resolution detailed a need for zero units of affordable housing presently and a prospective need for 212 units, following negotiations with the New Jersey Builders Association. This endorsement marked a milestone in the borough’s planning efforts for the next decade.
Police matters were also a key focus during the meeting. A collaborative investigation between Sergeant Di Maria and the Northvale Police Department addressed a shoplifting case at CVS, utilizing Automated License Plate Recognition (ALPR) cameras to identify suspects. Initially met with skepticism, the cameras’ success in this case validated their installation. In another police-related matter, the council acknowledged the Old Tappan Police Department’s assistance during the funeral services for Captain Wicker of the Englewood Cliffs Police Department, highlighting the camaraderie within the public safety community.
Traffic safety was discussed concerning the intersection of Orangeburg Road and Old Tappan Road, where improvements had reduced the number of annual accidents. However, concerns remained, with speculation about the causes, such as distracted driving. Traffic congestion on Charles Street was another issue, prompting discussions about potential solutions to alleviate resident access difficulties during peak hours.
The meeting concluded with the introduction of two ordinances for first reading. Ordinance number 1292-26 aimed to amend the police department ordinance, while ordinance number 1293-26 sought to update the stormwater control ordinance to align with state regulations. Both ordinances received unanimous support and were scheduled for further consideration at an upcoming meeting.
Thomas Gallagher
City Council Officials:
Ron Binaghi Jr., WILLIAM BOYCE (Council President), Juan Marti, Cort Gwon, Christine Massaro, Jin Yhu
-
Meeting Type:
City Council
-
Committee:
-
Meeting Date:
03/16/2026
-
Recording Published:
04/02/2026
-
Duration:
52 Minutes
-
Notability Score:
Routine
Receive debriefs about local meetings in your inbox weekly:
-
State:
New Jersey
-
County:
Bergen County
-
Towns:
Old Tappan
Recent Meetings Nearby:
- 04/13/2026
- 04/14/2026
- 25 Minutes
- 04/13/2026
- 04/13/2026
- 46 Minutes
- 04/13/2026
- 04/14/2026
- 73 Minutes