Rachel Cohen, advocating for Palestinian, Arab, and Muslim rights, criticized the HRC for retracting a post that she believed was an act of solidarity with Palestinians but was seen by some as terrorist sympathizing and anti-Semitism. She also questioned the appointment of a new commissioner who moderates a Facebook group accused of sharing Islamophobic content and allowing violent threats, including the doxing of minors. This concern was echoed throughout the meeting as multiple residents called for greater inclusion of Palestinian and Muslim voices in HRC activities and proposed events like an Interfaith vigil and healing circle that would involve the broader community.

An discussion ensued over the HRC’s response to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Several residents expressed their need for a balanced approach that acknowledges the pain and experiences of both Palestinians and Israelis. Stephanie Leone urged the HRC to reflect on its role in serving all community members without bias. A resident highlighted the absence of condemnation for Hamas, which was met with a rebuttal from another attendee stating that Hamas is not recognized by the government as a terrorist organization. Chair Elizabeth Milhim stressed the importance of maintaining a respectful space for these discussions and suggested focusing on suggestions for moving forward as a community.

The meeting also addressed broader concerns about social media’s role in the community. A virtual speaker highlighted the rise of anti-Semitism and Islamophobia and the inappropriate treatment of a visibly Muslim Arab woman. Others emphasized the need for mutual respect and education to understand the feelings of both Palestinians and Jewish people. The HRC commissioners, including Dr. Joyce Harley and Amy Gallatin, defended their positions and statements on Facebook, with a focus on listening to both sides of the conflict and promoting the HRC’s mission of addressing discrimination.

Councilwoman Susan McCartney commended the courage of those speaking out and called for respectful dialogue. Maria Vera and Temeshia N. Lemons echoed the importance of mutual respect and understanding in the community. The HRC’s participation in the upcoming Martin Luther King event was discussed, with the theme “Living the Dream: It Starts with Me – Spreading Hope, Courage, and Unity.” The committee debated the allocation of funds for the event and the creation of a video compilation, eventually approving a $125 expenditure.

The committee also tackled the issue of social media conduct among its members, with a focus on creating a distinction between personal opinions and official statements. The HRC emphasized the need for mindfulness and the importance of their roles as public figures. The members discussed the responsibility that comes with leadership positions and the significance of clear protocols for social media use.