Islamorada Council Debates Ride-Sharing Service Amid Concerns Over Costs and Service Quality
- Meeting Overview:
During the recent Islamorada Village Council meeting, the council tackled various issues, with the proposed renewal of a ride-sharing service taking center stage. The service, operated by Freebie, faced scrutiny from both council members and the public regarding its cost-effectiveness and quality of service. Additionally, the council addressed matters concerning zoning amendments, building permit allocations, and administrative relief applications.
The ride-sharing service has been important for residents lacking personal transportation, offering essential travel options like commuting and grocery shopping. However, concerns were raised over the financial implications and operational logistics of continuing with Freebie. The current contract, with an annual payment of $553,000, includes a $120,000 advertising credit. A representative clarified that the actual cost is $673,000, but the village would only pay the lower amount if advertising revenue falls short. Public comments highlighted skepticism about cost estimates and the burden on taxpayers. One speaker urged the council to monitor service delivery closely and ensure financial accountability. Community members also raised concerns about Freebie’s performance, pointing to excessive wait times and the need for more vehicles during peak periods.
Council members debated the merits of a one-year versus a two-year contract with Freebie, considering the “cancel by convenience” clause for flexibility. A member argued for a one-year trial to assess the service’s performance before committing long-term. The council eventually voted 4-1 in favor of continuing with Freebie, acknowledging its established track record and customer satisfaction. Despite the decision, the council recognized the ongoing need for oversight and potential adjustments to the service, such as exploring designated stops or a loop transit system to enhance efficiency.
In a related discussion, the council examined an application for administrative relief concerning a property on East Ridge Road. The application sought relief from the building permit allocation system due to repeated unsuccessful attempts to secure an allocation award. The council faced challenges in verifying the property’s legal status and debated whether previous approvals should influence current decisions. Public comments added to the complexity, with concerns about the property’s history and its impact on nearby homeowners. Ultimately, the council voted against the administrative relief application, opting to defer the matter pending an appraisal to explore purchasing the land for public use.
The council also addressed zoning amendments for a property on Old Highway, successfully passing changes to the future land use designation and zoning from multifamily to settlers residential. This decision supports maintaining the single-family use intended by the current property owners.
Additionally, the meeting explored the status of building permit allocations and the BP pass list, with council members expressing concerns about fairness and the potential impact of future legislative changes. The council acknowledged the need for a comprehensive understanding of the allocation process and potential restructuring to better accommodate applicants, particularly those employed within the community.
Sharon Mahoney
City Council Officials:
Don Horton (Vice Mayor), Joseph “Buddy” Pinder III, Deb Gillis, Steve Friedman
-
Meeting Type:
City Council
-
Committee:
-
Meeting Date:
06/11/2026
-
Recording Published:
06/12/2026
-
Duration:
118 Minutes
-
Notability Score:
Routine
Receive debriefs about local meetings in your inbox weekly:
-
State:
Florida
-
County:
Monroe County
-
Towns:
Islamorada
Recent Meetings Nearby:
- 06/22/2026
- 227 Minutes
- 06/22/2026
- 06/22/2026
- 291 Minutes
- 06/18/2026
- 06/18/2026
- 197 Minutes