Old Tappan Planning Board Weighs Golf Pavilion Proposal Amid Zoning and Noise Concerns
- Meeting Overview:
The Old Tappan Planning Board meeting was marked by a discussion surrounding a proposed golf pavilion, which raised significant zoning and noise concerns, as well as broader deliberations on state legislation impacting local land use and zoning regulations. The board also considered the implications of upcoming changes to the town’s master plan and discussed adjustments to application and escrow fees.
The most pressing topic at the meeting was the proposal for a golf pavilion designed to house a golf simulator on an existing sports court. The applicant sought a variance to increase the floor area ratio (FAR) from 21.8% to 23.1%, above the maximum allowable 22%. The board scrutinized the proposal’s compliance with zoning codes, especially regarding noise and runoff management. The pavilion would not alter the impervious surface area, as it would be erected on the current court, but the roof’s slant and rainwater management system drew attention. The architectural details, including a sloped roof and trench drain, were reviewed to ensure proper drainage and minimal impact on surrounding properties.
Concerns also centered on the potential noise generated by the golf simulator, which could peak between 75 and 120 decibels. The board discussed the need for soundproofing measures to mitigate disturbances to neighboring properties, particularly given the pavilion’s year-round use capability. The potential noise reduction compared to the previous use of the sports court for pickleball, known for its loud play, was noted as an improvement. The architect assured that sound attenuation materials would be considered to address these concerns.
The pavilion’s design, featuring fixed glass panels and a mini-split heating and cooling system, was also scrutinized. Questions about the glass panels’ durability against stray golf balls and the adequacy of the ceiling height for simulator use were raised. The board emphasized the need for proper construction techniques to mitigate water seepage and considered whether the height was sufficient for the golf balls’ trajectory. The proposed structure’s aesthetics and functionality were debated, with suggestions to vary the height for aesthetic purposes.
In addition to the pavilion, the board examined several potential legislative changes affecting local land use. The proposed state bills could impact zoning laws, including a bill permitting the conversion of religious facilities into inclusionary housing developments and another allowing accessory dwelling units (ADUs) in single-family zones. Concerns were voiced about the implications for local zoning, particularly the conversion of religious structures into multifamily residences and the potential requirement for ADUs to adhere to affordable housing mandates.
The board also discussed a bill regarding the redevelopment of economically struggling office parks and retail centers into mixed-use residential developments. The feasibility of meeting a 45-day application review period was questioned, given the financial criteria for redevelopment. The board expressed skepticism about the support from the League of Municipalities, based on previous experiences with affordable housing regulations.
A draft of the town’s master plan is anticipated, with a review session planned for July 8. The board discussed whether to integrate the legislative changes into the master plan, emphasizing the need for quick adaptation to potential state overrides. Adjustments to application and escrow fees were also considered, with current amounts deemed inadequate for covering development application demands. A committee may be formed to reevaluate fee structures.
In old business, the board addressed timing for zoning and code changes related to the master plan. A major subdivision application on Olds Pan Road was denied after public hearings, while a minor subdivision on Herring was approved. A new variance application for an accessory structure on Cedar Drive was introduced, with discussions on its completeness and the necessity of requested waivers.
Thomas Gallagher
Planning Board Officials:
Juan Marti, Thomas Jung, William Boyce, Charles Maggio, Nick Mamary, Michael Alessi, David Keil, Nicki Louloudis, Robert Scozzafava, Vicken Bedian Alt #1, Michael Azarian Alt #2, John M. Kramer Alt #3, Sam Petrocelli Alt #4, Robert Regan, Esq. (Board Attorney), Thomas Skrable (Borough Engineer), John Szabo (Planner), Jennifer Boehm (Land Use Secretary)
-
Meeting Type:
Planning Board
-
Committee:
-
Meeting Date:
06/10/2026
-
Recording Published:
07/15/2026
-
Duration:
79 Minutes
-
Notability Score:
Routine
Receive debriefs about local meetings in your inbox weekly:
-
State:
New Jersey
-
County:
Bergen County
-
Towns:
Old Tappan
Recent Meetings Nearby:
- 07/23/2026
- 07/23/2026
- 14 Minutes
- 07/22/2026
- 362 Minutes
- 07/22/2026
- 07/22/2026
- 12 Minutes