Amherst Committee Debates Town Manager’s Goals and Community Engagement Strategies
-
Meeting Type:
Oversight and Review Committee
-
Meeting Date:
12/05/2024
-
Recording Published:
12/06/2024
-
Duration:
169 Minutes
-
State:
Massachusetts
-
County:
Hampshire County
-
Towns:
Amherst
- Meeting Overview:
During a recent meeting of the Amherst Governance, Organization, and Legislation Committee, members engaged in discussions on setting clear and actionable goals for the town manager, Paul Bockelman, while also addressing the broader community’s needs. The deliberations included a comprehensive evaluation of the town manager’s objectives, focusing on climate action, community well-being, and housing and economic vitality. The committee aimed to streamline these goals into three primary objectives to ensure they were both manageable and impactful.
The meeting began with a debate on the restructuring of the town manager’s goals. George Ryan introduced a new working document proposing a condensed structure, reducing the previous five policy areas into three main objectives. This proposal sparked a discussion among committee members who expressed differing views on the specificity and clarity required for these objectives. Concerns were raised about the vagueness of certain phrases, such as “support the development of climate action,” prompting calls for more precise language to avoid potential misunderstandings. Some members advocated for retaining multiple objectives under each goal to address all aspects comprehensively and to allow for a nuanced evaluation of the town manager’s performance.
Another focal point of the meeting was the importance of incorporating a “climate lens” into the town’s objectives, although the term was criticized for its lack of definition. Members emphasized the necessity for clear articulation. The conversation highlighted the need for the town manager to take a stance in crafting these items.
The discussion on climate action items delved into the practical steps the town could take, such as transitioning municipal vehicles to electric options and leveraging funds from the Inflation Reduction Act. Participants debated the feasibility and clarity of proposed actions, with suggestions to replace vague timelines with specific criteria for transitioning away from fossil fuels. There was a consensus on the importance of protecting staff resources and avoiding overburdening the council with numerous new proposals without considering their feasibility.
The committee also addressed community health and safety, integrating social justice into their considerations. Members affirmed the need to evaluate community responder programs and review public safety protocols continually. The topic of youth empowerment programming was debated, with a consensus emerging to remove it from immediate objectives due to varied feedback and lack of clear direction.
In parallel, the committee explored strategies for racial and social justice, proposing the creation of an advisory council to gather input from marginalized communities. While some questioned the necessity of this action item, noting existing efforts to include community input, the committee agreed on the value of establishing clear and specific objectives to avoid ambiguity.
The town manager’s performance evaluation was another significant topic, highlighting the challenges of aligning expectations with responsibilities. Concerns were voiced about holding the town manager accountable for tasks not formally assigned to him, emphasizing the need for clarity in the council’s directives. The committee discussed the organizational structure and the demands placed on the town manager, with suggestions for an external review to assess the distribution of responsibilities and identify areas for improvement.
Additionally, the committee considered proposals to address gender bias in salaries and supervisory responsibilities. This topic was deemed critical, with references to previous dialogues with the HR Director and the necessity for ongoing discussions. The challenges of speeding up the hiring process for vacant positions were also acknowledged, given the constraints of the charter and the competitive job market.
Communication with residents emerged as a key issue, with proposals for clearer pathways to assist those seeking help with various issues. The idea of a single point of contact for residents was discussed, although concerns were raised about its practicality and scope. The committee agreed on the importance of enhancing communication through clearer directives on the town’s website.
The meeting concluded with a resolution to withdraw a specific proposal due to its budgetary implications, shifting focus to alternative methods to achieve the intended outcomes. A proclamation recognizing Kwanzaa week was also reviewed, with members making necessary grammatical changes and ensuring community participation.
Paul Brockelman
Oversight and Review Committee Officials:
Ana Devlin Gauthier, Pat De Angelis, Ndifreke Ette, Lynn Griesemer, George Ryan, Athena O’Keeffe (Clerk of the Council)
-
Meeting Type:
Oversight and Review Committee
-
Committee:
-
Meeting Date:
12/05/2024
-
Recording Published:
12/06/2024
-
Duration:
169 Minutes
-
Notability Score:
Routine
Receive debriefs about local meetings in your inbox weekly:
-
State:
Massachusetts
-
County:
Hampshire County
-
Towns:
Amherst
Recent Meetings Nearby:
- 12/23/2024
- 12/23/2024
- 75 Minutes
- 12/23/2024
- 12/24/2024
- 56 Minutes