Amherst Conservation Commission Debates Safety of Hunting on Conservation Lands Amid Trail Expansion

The Amherst Conservation Commission’s recent meeting discussed the safety and regulations of hunting on conservation lands, particularly in the context of expanding trail networks and public safety concerns. The conversation also touched on updating the town’s website, maintaining existing trails, and the draft dog use policy.

0:00The primary concern of the meeting was the legality and safety of hunting on conservation lands. A detailed map illustrating the boundaries of conservation lands and hunting-permitted areas was presented. The map included a 500-foot buffer around roads, trails, and structures to address safety concerns, which prompted a debate among members regarding its implications. Questions arose about whether the 500-foot buffer from trails was a legal requirement or a guideline, with clarifications provided that it was based on Massachusetts law concerning occupied residences and did not apply to unoccupied structures.

A key point of contention was the interpretation of the map and the overlap of trail prohibitions within designated hunting areas. Some members expressed confusion about whether hunting should be allowed in these overlapping locations. It was emphasized that the buffer zones were not legal prohibitions but rather a safety assessment tool. The historical context of no reported hunting accidents in the past two decades was considered crucial for evaluating current policies.

36:25Further discussion highlighted the challenges of defining specific areas for different types of hunting. Members debated whether to prohibit hunting altogether in the town’s conservation areas. Personal experiences shared by members underscored the inherent risks of hunting near public recreational areas, particularly with families and children on the trails.

The conversation also ventured into the need for a clear and concise recommendation to present to the commission. A straightforward explanation of hunting areas using a simple map was suggested to minimize confusion among users and ensure compliance with safety standards. The urgency to finalize discussions by the end of December was noted, with a call for ongoing discussions and potential amendments to hunting policies.

19:27In addition to hunting regulations, the commission addressed the outdated and inconsistent state of its website. One individual highlighted the need for an accurate and updated online presence to inform residents and visitors about conservation land use policies. This issue was deemed important for effective communication and enforcement of regulations.

The maintenance of the existing approximately 80 miles of trails was another significant topic. One member expressed a preference to prioritize maintaining current trails over expanding the trail network, citing challenges in keeping the existing trails open and passable. This perspective suggested focusing conservation efforts on the existing lands to ensure their usability and safety.

36:25The draft dog use policy was also briefly discussed, with no comments received on the draft, allowing the commission to move past this agenda item quickly. The proposal to present the forestry section of the land use policy, reportedly close to completion, to the commission for review and comment was made. The idea of systematically presenting sections of the policy for feedback at subsequent meetings was suggested, with the expectation that a public hearing would be necessary to codify the final document.

Note: This meeting summary was generated by AI, which can occasionally misspell names, misattribute actions, and state inaccuracies. This summary is intended to be a starting point and you should review the meeting record linked above before acting on anything you read. If we got something wrong, let us know. We’re working every day to improve our process in pursuit of universal local government transparency.

Receive debriefs about local meetings in your inbox weekly:

is discussed during:
in these locations: