25:40The architectural presentation on the staircase revealed several key compliance issues, notably the inadequate height and spacing of the spindles, and the excessive overhang of the treads’ nosing. These features do not meet modern safety standards, posing potential hazards. The architect highlighted these challenges, noting that older buildings often lack modern safety dimensions, particularly regarding stair nosing.

To address these issues, the architect proposed new handrails—one attached to the wall and another positioned inboard of the existing historic rail. Despite these efforts, concerns persisted about the staircase being an “attractive nuisance.” Participants discussed liability if users inadvertently chose the non-compliant staircase over the newly installed compliant options, which include three new staircases and an elevator for full library access. Clear signage was suggested to inform users of the non-compliant status and limited access of the historic staircase.

33:50The council also examined the broader library entrance modifications, which are intended to eliminate the need for stairs, thereby enhancing accessibility. The existing entrance, characterized by a pinch point, will be redesigned to accommodate two wheelchairs passing simultaneously. Members raised concerns about visibility for visually impaired users, advocating for lowering adjacent windows to improve sight lines and prevent accidents from outward-opening doors.

43:26Further discussions explored interior design elements, emphasizing the need for color contrast to aid navigation, particularly for those with vision impairments. Members stressed the importance of practical design choices that go beyond mere compliance. The dialogue highlighted the potential for muted color schemes to cause confusion, advocating for varied colors and textures around stair edges to enhance safety.

The significance of tactile markers on steps was also debated, with the architect initially suggesting granite strips. However, these were deemed ineffective for guiding users, prompting calls for alternative tactile solutions to be integrated into the final design.

39:14As the meeting concluded, the council unanimously approved a motion to support a variance request for the library, contingent upon adequate safety signage. The commitment to preserving the staircase’s historical value while prioritizing user safety and accessibility was a recurring theme throughout the discussions.

Members recognized the importance of design choices that accommodate the diverse needs of library users.