Bayonne City Council Discusses Historic Preservation Amid Ongoing St. Andrew’s Church Lawsuit
- Meeting Overview:
The Bayonne City Council meeting focused on historic preservation efforts across the city, with particular attention to the status of St. Andrew’s Church, a proposal to demolish a home on Airs Court, and the nomination of properties with significant historical value. Discussions were also held on the redevelopment of the Uptown synagogue and the potential landmark status for several properties, including a dry dock facility and local churches significant to Black history.
0:09The meeting’s most pressing topic was the ongoing situation with St. Andrew’s Church, recently designated a historic site by the city council. However, its future remains uncertain due to an ongoing lawsuit involving parishioners, which could influence the church’s reuse. A commissioner emphasized the need for proper documentation to secure funding for any potential constructive reuse of the property. The council acknowledged procedural issues in past documentation practices and stressed improved communication to avoid hindrances in future projects. The possibility of seeking grant money was discussed, with the aim of maintaining the building without requiring it to function as a church.
The council also discussed a new proposal to demolish a single-family home at 9-11 Airs Court, dating back to around 1960, and replace it with two two-family houses. This proposal did not face objections from the commissioners, although it sparked a broader discussion on the handling of historic properties within Bayonne. There was a consensus on the need for collaboration among commissioners to ensure effective management of such properties, emphasizing patience and thoroughness given the complexities involved.
16:57In a related matter, one council member highlighted their personal involvement in a property nomination process linked to the Solen Humph project, which features 25 houses.
The council explored various future property reports, including research into the historical Bayonne Dry Dock and Repair facility. Articles from 1939 detailing the Navy’s initial interest in acquiring local properties for military purposes were reviewed, noting the dry dock’s transformation into a significant naval facility and later a military ocean terminal. The council expressed interest in pursuing landmark status for a 1940s-era building within the facility.
An initiative focusing on the Black history of Bayonne was introduced, highlighting several local churches as potential landmarks. These churches, including Angelic Baptist, Friendship Baptist, Goala Temple, and the Evangelical Gospel Tabernacle, contribute to the community’s historical narrative. The council seemed inclined to preserve these sites to enrich Bayonne’s cultural history.
The redevelopment of the Uptown synagogue was another focal point, with a congregation member expressing a desire to either preserve the building or create a memorial if preservation proved unfeasible. The council members showed a willingness to collaborate with the congregation to honor the building’s history, reflecting sentiments from previous redevelopments in the area.
Additionally, the historical significance of Forester Place was briefly discussed, noting a gap in information about its context and origins. There was curiosity about its name, contrasting it with other historically significant figures in the area.
Finally, a concern was raised about the preservation of the old Mechanics Trust Bank building on West 8th Street, believed to be constructed around 1902. A request was made to assess the city’s plans for the building, highlighting the desire to preserve its historical integrity for future use.
Jimmy Davis
City Council Officials:
Neil Carroll III, Jacqueline Weimmer, Gary La Pelusa Sr., Loyad Booker, Juan M. Perez
-
Meeting Type:
City Council
-
Committee:
-
Meeting Date:
02/25/2025
-
Recording Published:
03/01/2025
-
Duration:
31 Minutes
-
Notability Score:
Routine
Receive debriefs about local meetings in your inbox weekly:
-
State:
New Jersey
-
County:
Hudson County
-
Towns:
Bayonne
Recent Meetings Nearby:
- 05/29/2025
- 05/30/2025
- 53 Minutes
- 05/29/2025
- 05/29/2025
- 29 Minutes