The discussion on Teen Night revealed a deep divide within the community. Many residents and visitors defended the event as a necessary and safe outlet for local youth. One speaker emphasized the importance of providing teenagers with a supervised environment, noting “idle teenagers will make problems or cause problems.” Gavin, a long-time visitor to Long Beach Island, echoed this sentiment, stating, “Teen Night is our shelter,” and expressed concern over changes in law enforcement behavior, including receiving a curfew ticket while waiting for a ride.

Frank Barelli supported Teen Night but cautioned against blaming the event for broader teenage issues in the area. He observed that teenage congregations occur every night, not just during Teen Night, and warned that ongoing discussions could lead to lawsuits, ultimately burdening taxpayers. Barelli urged the council to collaborate with local businesses, which are integral to the community’s economic foundation.

Brody Goldin, a teenager, reinforced the idea that Teen Night offers a safe space, arguing that issues arise when teenagers are left unsupervised. He praised the Marlin as a well-managed venue that contributes positively to the nightlife for young people in the area.

On the opposing side, Gary Berser expressed strong opposition, describing the gatherings as “rude adolescence… disturbing the peace in our area.” He suggested that the issue lies within parenting, advocating for stricter discipline at home. Berser shared his personal experience with corporal punishment, implying that such discipline had a positive impact on his development.

Emma Kby pointed out that Teen Night reduced problems associated with teenagers in uncontrolled environments, emphasizing it provides a secure alternative. CJ Mac commented on the improvements at the Marlin.

During the meeting, the council also discussed several ordinances. Ordinance 2024-23c, concerning amendments to the limousine code, was unanimously approved after a brief public discussion. Ordinance 2024-24c, related to a lease amendment and extension with the Beach Haven Volunteer Fire Company for premises on Pelum Avenue, was presented for a final reading. Chief Adam Far detailed the initiative to establish a living program for volunteer firefighters, intended to enhance response capabilities during the summer.

Ordinance 2024-25c mandated that full-time and part-time employees be paid through direct deposit to streamline payroll processes and reduce material costs, which passed without public comments. Ordinance 2024-26c proposed revisions to definitions related to the prohibition of teen night, sparking the debate detailed above.

Environmental concerns were also raised during the meeting. Kathy King expressed worries about dust and debris from the Pier 18 project affecting nearby properties. She questioned whether the particles had been tested for potential health impacts and urged the council for transparency. Michael Pugs entered the discussion but faced interruptions, leading to a brief disruption.

Mary Lee Pence provided clarification regarding a recent court ruling favoring the town, which was subsequently appealed. She informed the audience that the Ocean County Superior Court’s decision was under appeal, sparking interest from attendees.

Charlie Coughlin spoke about development in Beach Haven, advocating for more multifamily housing to benefit the local economy. He emphasized the importance of local projects and expressed a nostalgic view on community development.

Concerns about current town signage, suggesting a curfew and encouraging locking cars, were raised by Bill Locky. He argued that the signs could deter tourists by implying safety issues. The council discussed the possibility of changing the sign’s placement or wording to improve the town’s image.

The public comment period concluded with a series of disrespectful remarks, prompting the council to close the floor to public comments. Council members expressed gratitude for community participation, with one addressing the challenges posed by negative comments from local youths.