Belmar Borough Council Addresses Affordable Housing Compliance Amid Potential Lawsuits
- Meeting Overview:
During a recent Belmar Borough Council meeting, attention was given to the borough’s ongoing efforts to meet its affordable housing obligations, with detailed presentations outlining potential legal consequences for non-compliance. Attorney Francancy McMahon and planner Christine Bell led a discussion on the borough’s affordable housing status, which has been a point of contention due to past inaction. The borough has faced mounting pressure to comply with the Mount Laurel doctrine, a constitutional obligation requiring municipalities to provide affordable housing. Over the past decade, Belmar has accrued a backlog of units that need to be constructed, and recent large-scale developments have failed to incorporate affordable housing, thus exposing the borough to builder’s remedy lawsuits.
02:34These lawsuits permit developers to circumvent local zoning laws if they include affordable housing in their projects, a concern given the borough’s current non-compliance. In response, Belmar filed a declaratory judgment in March 2023, seeking temporary immunity from such lawsuits while aiming to negotiate with developers to include affordable units in new projects. McMahon highlighted several key developments, including the Mark Belt project on River Road, which successfully negotiated an increase in affordable units from zero to 24. The Repetti Russo project on Route 35 also adjusted its plans to incorporate 20 affordable units and a $2 million contribution to the borough’s affordable housing trust fund.
13:45Public feedback was solicited, with residents like Stu Graater and Sandy Caputo voicing concerns about the adequacy and enforcement of affordable housing measures. Graater questioned the possibility of retroactively acquiring affordable units from previous developments, while Caputo scrutinized the Mediterranean project’s compliance, which provides only half the typical requirement of affordable units. This led to discussions about the borough’s strategy, which includes negotiating compromises with developers regarding project scale and additional contributions to the trust fund.
19:23The meeting also addressed the operational constraints of the affordable housing trust fund, which had grown from zero to $156,762 by April 2023. However, its use is contingent upon court approval of the housing element fair share plan. Concerns were raised about the implications of not approving a proposed ordinance, which could result in legal challenges from Fair Share Housing, a watchdog organization. Discussions touched on the potential loss of local zoning control, which could lead to denser developments.
25:22During public comments, individuals expressed concerns regarding the transparency and fairness of the borough’s approach to local businesses and development projects. A resident questioned the Mediterranean project’s compliance with its affordable housing commitments, confirming that the developer met a 15% affordable unit requirement alongside financial contributions. The council also discussed the third and fourth rounds of affordable housing obligations, noting that administrative delays have extended timelines, with the fourth round expected to start in July 2025.
34:49In other topics, the council highlighted community engagement and events, such as a successful Belmar Environmental Committee beach cleanup and preparation for the upcoming Seafood Festival. The council also recognized the efforts of the Belmar Youth Club and local Eagle Scouts for their contributions to the community. However, discussions about the surf camp bidding process dominated part of the public session, with residents expressing discontent over perceived inconsistencies in how local businesses are treated.
01:06:24Concerns about concession stand leases were also raised, with operators seeking clarification on terms and expressing frustration over infrastructure issues, such as inadequate electrical services. The council acknowledged these challenges and assured ongoing discussions to address them.
01:08:08Infrastructure improvements were another focal point, with updates on road paving projects and discussions about potential solutions for house numbering to aid emergency services. A proposal to reinstate a sidewalk repair program was also suggested, emphasizing the need for safe pedestrian pathways.
Gerald Buccafusco
City Council Officials:
Mark Levis, Maria Rondinaro, Caitlin Donovan, Jodi Kinney
-
Meeting Type:
City Council
-
Committee:
-
Meeting Date:
03/25/2025
-
Recording Published:
03/26/2025
-
Duration:
71 Minutes
-
Notability Score:
Routine
Receive debriefs about local meetings in your inbox weekly:
-
State:
New Jersey
-
County:
Monmouth County
-
Towns:
Belmar
Recent Meetings Nearby:
- 06/11/2025
- 06/11/2025
- 49 Minutes
- 06/11/2025
- 06/11/2025
- 242 Minutes
- 06/11/2025
- 06/11/2025
- 30 Minutes