Bernards Zoning Board Denies Fence Variance Amid Neighborhood Security Concerns
- Meeting Overview:
The recent Bernards Zoning Board meeting was marked by a debate over a proposed variance for a residential fence that sparked considerable controversy among residents and board members. The board ultimately denied the application, which sought to construct a seven-foot-high entry gate and masonry columns, citing concerns about neighborhood character and security justification. Other discussions included a swimming pool variance and an application for a substantial home addition, both of which highlighted ongoing community concerns about zoning regulations and neighborhood aesthetics.
37:46The meeting’s most contentious issue involved the proposed variance for a property on Beaver Creek Court, where the applicant sought to install a seven-foot-high entry gate and masonry columns, exceeding the local ordinance’s four-foot height limit. The applicant cited security concerns following a burglary incident involving their son. The proposal included black metal gates and masonry columns, intended to blend aesthetically with the surrounding vegetation.
01:42:39During the public comment period, several residents expressed strong opposition to the variance, arguing that the proposed structure was inconsistent with the neighborhood’s open character. Concerns were raised about the visual impact of the columns and gate, with residents noting that no other homes in the immediate area featured similar structures. They feared that granting such a variance would set a precedent, potentially leading to a proliferation of similar applications that could alter the neighborhood’s traditional aesthetic.
02:07:08The board members engaged in a discussion about the necessity and implications of the proposed fence. Some questioned whether the security concerns justified the variance. The debate also touched on the technical requirements for the proposed structure, including its classification as a fence under local zoning ordinances. Ultimately, the board concluded that the application did not meet the criteria for approval, and a motion to deny the variance was passed unanimously.
10:26Another agenda item was the review of a variance application for a swimming pool on a residential property. The applicants sought approval for a pool placement that deviated from zoning requirements, arguing that the strategic positioning would allow for better visibility from the home while adhering to environmental regulations. The board examined the proposal’s compliance with drainage and lighting standards, and the applicants confirmed their intent to meet all stipulated conditions. Public concerns about potential flooding and drainage were addressed with assurances of effective stormwater management.
02:20:29The meeting also featured a detailed presentation from Lindy Ponucci, who applied for variances related to a home addition and pool on Pittney Court. The proposal included reducing driveway size and adding raised decking to decrease overall coverage. Ponucci emphasized the need for additional space to support her family, particularly her son with behavioral challenges. The proposal was supported by visual aids and testimonies from an architect and engineer.
02:01:09Residents and board members alike grappled with balancing security needs against maintaining the character of their neighborhoods.
Janice M. Fields
Zoning Board Officials:
Jeanmarie Genirs, David Tancredi, Beth Pochtar, Lisamarie Baumann, Anil Agrawal, Karl Kraus, Kippy Piedici, Elizabeth Silver, Steven K. Warner, Esq. (Board Attorney), Thomas J. Quinn PE, CME (Board Engineer), David L. Schley, AICP/PP (Board Planner), Cyndi Kiefer (Board Secretary)
-
Meeting Type:
Zoning Board
-
Committee:
-
Meeting Date:
06/04/2025
-
Recording Published:
06/04/2025
-
Duration:
204 Minutes
-
Notability Score:
Routine
Receive debriefs about local meetings in your inbox weekly:
-
State:
New Jersey
-
County:
Somerset County
-
Towns:
Bernards
Recent Meetings Nearby:
- 06/19/2025
- 06/19/2025
- 265 Minutes
- 06/19/2025
- 06/20/2025
- 135 Minutes
- 06/19/2025
- 06/19/2025
- 122 Minutes