Boston School Committee Faces Backlash Over Proposed School Closures Amid Budget Discussions

The Boston School Committee meeting focused heavily on the proposed closures of several schools, including the deor Elementary School and Community Academy, amidst discussions on the Fiscal Year 2026 budget. Speakers voiced strong opposition to these closures, emphasizing the potential negative impacts on vulnerable communities. The budget proposal, which includes a $53.4 million increase, was also discussed, highlighting a focus on enhancing academic performance and maintaining high-quality learning opportunities.

2:20:11The proposed closures of the deor Elementary School and Community Academy dominated the meeting, with numerous speakers expressing deep concerns about the repercussions for students and their communities. A teacher from the deor school described the closure as “an act of cruelty against our immigrant families,” arguing that it would uproot families already facing significant hardships. This sentiment was echoed by others who criticized the lack of meaningful community engagement in the decision-making process. Concerns were raised about the inconsistency in data provided by Boston Public Schools (BPS), particularly relating to the capacity and quality of facilities at the deor school. One speaker pointed out that the school has a higher facility score than many other BPS schools not considered for closure, raising questions about the rationale behind targeting this particular school.

Community Academy was also defended as an essential support system for students who often come from challenging backgrounds. A guidance counselor noted that the school acts as a “lifeline,” providing a nurturing environment for students who may struggle in traditional settings. A former student shared their personal journey, highlighting the support and guidance received at Community Academy, which was pivotal in their educational success. The proposed closure was strongly opposed, with speakers emphasizing that the school serves students that other schools may not want to admit, including those with long-term suspensions or significant attendance issues.

1:58:37Public comments further underscored the emotional weight of the proposed school closures. Parents, teachers, and community members conveyed their concerns, stressing the need for community engagement and support rather than decisions made without stakeholder consultation. One parent mentor highlighted the transformative impact of their program, noting that it enabled parents to take on new roles within the district and motivated them to pursue teaching careers. Another speaker questioned the decision-making processes within BPS, criticizing the disconnect between district policies and the needs of students from immigrant families.

24:05The budget discussion revealed a $53.4 million increase aimed at advancing district priorities, which include enhancing academic performance and maintaining consistency in high-quality learning opportunities. However, the proposal also includes an $8 million cut in support for multilingual learners, sparking concerns about the impact on bilingual teachers and aides. This reduction would affect 71 positions, raising questions about how these budgetary decisions align with the district’s goals for improving access to native language instruction.

Efforts to ensure fiscal responsibility were highlighted, with mentions of reviewing vacancies and adjusting contracted services to achieve savings without compromising quality. These efficiency measures have led to significant cost savings, which are reinvested into programs aimed at enhancing student learning and well-being. The central office budget, which consists of four main components—academics, the office of family and community engagement, operations, and the superintendent’s office—was also discussed. The meeting was structured to allow for questions and suggestions from committee members and the community.

1:40:21Transportation issues were another focal point, particularly concerning the alignment of bus schedules with charter and Catholic schools. An official noted ongoing collaboration with these schools to adjust schedules, although BPS cannot mandate these changes. The budget includes a planned investment of $6 million for new classrooms, which would support various student needs, including programs for students with disabilities.

Note: This meeting summary was generated by AI, which can occasionally misspell names, misattribute actions, and state inaccuracies. This summary is intended to be a starting point and you should review the meeting record linked above before acting on anything you read. If we got something wrong, let us know. We’re working every day to improve our process in pursuit of universal local government transparency.

Receive debriefs about local meetings in your inbox weekly:

Trending meetings
across the country: