The meeting, held on April 1, 2025, addressed issues, but the focal point was the discussion around the historical significance of the property on Old Harbor Road. The commission reaffirmed its historical value with a unanimous motion. This decision was further supported by an update from the contractor overseeing the remodeling project. The contractor detailed the necessity of removing the compromised porch framing, a discovery made during the extensive three-year renovation of the property. The homeowner’s enthusiasm for the increased natural light and the contractor’s proposal to accentuate the original front door and dining room features led to a broader consensus on the aesthetic and historical benefits of the change.

Members agreed that the removal of the porch, likely added 80 to 100 years ago, would enhance the home’s Greek Revival architecture. The consensus was that this would not only maintain but improve the property’s historical integrity. This decision also opened the possibility for the property to be considered for a preservation award in 2024, should the restoration be completed by then. The award recognizes exemplary efforts in preserving historical structures, further highlighting the community’s dedication to its architectural heritage.

The meeting also covered updates on other key projects, including the Ann and William Nicholson homestead. The commission is awaiting a determination of eligibility from Massachusetts Historic, with expectations for a response within 30 to 60 days. This process is part of ongoing funding discussions to secure the necessary resources for the next phase of work, estimated between $10,000 to $15,000.

Another topic of concern was the issue of demolition by neglect, which highlights properties that risk losing their historical value due to lack of maintenance. The commission is anticipating a staff report from the principal planner.

The commission also discussed the relocation and reconstruction of the Coast Guard boathouse, for which the town has issued a request for services to hire an owner’s project manager. This step is important for ensuring that the historical character of the boathouse is preserved during its relocation.

Additionally, the commission reviewed the ongoing situation regarding the 1550 Main Street housing development, a 40B project. Concerns had previously been raised by the Historical Business District Commission about the design’s lack of variety and the absence of a community center. The developer has yet to submit a comprehensive permit request to the Zoning Board of Adjustment, an action that would trigger further reviews and comments from the Historical Commission and other boards. The commission expressed a clear desire for substantial revisions to these proposals to ensure that historical preservation is adequately considered in the development process.

The meeting concluded with a discussion on the scheduling of future sessions. Members noted the potential cancellation of a meeting on the 15th due to a lack of applications, with plans to convene only if issues arose. The commission confirmed at least two applications for the subsequent meeting.