The School Street project drew particular attention due to its focus on restoring the historic character of the home. Board members expressed strong support for the removal of vinyl siding, viewing it as a positive step towards preserving the architectural integrity of the neighborhood. One member commented, “Anything that can get vinyl siding off of an old house is great,” illustrating the board’s enthusiasm for the restoration effort. The project also included an addition primarily located below grade and behind the house, designed to minimize visual impact from the street.

Despite the general approval, the project sparked debate over a feature known as the “Koopa,” which some members felt detracted from the design. The discussion revealed divided opinions, with some members advocating for its exclusion, stating it made the garage appear out of place in the historic district. Others argued that the Koopa could enhance the overall aesthetic without overwhelming the historic qualities of the house. Ultimately, the board approved the application, including the Koopa, with conditions to regulate construction timing and vehicle access during the renovation process.

Another topic was the approval of an accessory dwelling unit (ADU) on Shane Drive, which required a special permit due to exceeding the maximum building coverage allowed by zoning regulations. The ADU, intended for the applicant’s mother, drew support from neighbors who emphasized its potential to provide affordable housing options in Chatham. Residents highlighted the challenges posed by high property prices, with one stating, “I think this is a really good test case for Chatham for more affordable housing.”

However, the application faced scrutiny due to health regulations, with concerns about nitrogen loading if the dwelling were to exceed its three-bedroom limit. The applicant addressed this by planning to convert one of the existing bedrooms into a den, complying with health department guidelines. The board ultimately approved the ADU, recognizing its alignment with community needs and state laws favoring such units.

The meeting also covered a proposal for a property on Main Street, where the Robert J. McCarron Trust sought to modify a non-conforming dwelling. The project involved partial demolition and the addition of new living spaces, while maintaining the existing building coverage. The board deliberated on the historical significance of the structure, formerly the Andrew Harding store, and its contribution to the neighborhood’s aesthetic. After discussing the potential impacts on the neighborhood’s character, the board unanimously approved the proposal with conditions to manage construction parking and noise.

Further discussions included a request to modify a property on Riverview Drive, where the McCormacks proposed an addition and deck to a non-conforming dwelling. The board addressed concerns from a direct abutter regarding visual impact and storm runoff but ultimately approved the application, emphasizing its compatibility with the surrounding area.