Cinnaminson School Board Faces Disparities in Student Assessment Scores and Addresses Community Concerns
- Meeting Overview:
The recent Cinnaminson School Board meeting delved into issues, including disparities in the New Jersey Student Learning Assessments (NJSLA) scores across different student subgroups. The board also addressed community concerns regarding special education placements and financial transparency, with public comments highlighting perceived shortcomings in these areas.
A focal point of the meeting was the detailed presentation of the NJSLA results for English Language Arts (ELA), mathematics, and science, which revealed notable disparities in performance among various student subgroups within the district. For ELA, the passing rates showed 76% of Asian students passed, compared to 64% of white students, 60% of multi-racial students, and lower rates for Hispanic and African-American students at 42% and 41%, respectively. A similar trend was observed in math scores, with Asian students achieving a 73% passing rate, while white students had 59%, multi-racial students 55%, and Hispanic and African-American students had passing rates of 35% and 33%, respectively. Economically disadvantaged students and those with special education needs also demonstrated lower passing rates, highlighting areas in need of targeted interventions.
During the presentation, the board emphasized the rigorous nature of the NJSLA, noting that assessments span multiple grade levels, particularly in science. Fifth-grade science assessments cover standards from third to fifth grade, creating challenging benchmarks for students. The board acknowledged the necessity of professional development to address these gaps, focusing on enhancing support for multilingual learners and students requiring additional assistance. Plans were outlined to incorporate manipulatives in mathematics instruction and embed science literacy activities within the curriculum to better align with assessment expectations.
The meeting also featured an update on the district’s advanced placement (AP) results from the previous academic year. A total of 212 AP tests were administered, with 82% of test takers earning scores of three or higher, qualifying them for college credit. The English Language and Composition course yielded impressive results, with 79% of students achieving scores of four or better. Similarly, calculus students performed well, with 14 out of 20 earning top scores of four or five.
Public comments during the meeting brought attention to specific community concerns. One parent, Scott Noiki, expressed dissatisfaction with his son’s removal from an integrated kindergarten classroom, where he felt his son was thriving. Noiki argued that this decision lacked credible justification and could potentially violate federal and state laws, such as the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act, by not adequately supporting students with disabilities. He urged the board to engage in active oversight and ensure compliance with legal obligations to avoid legal and financial risks.
Another community member, Brittany Relvis, voiced frustration over the district’s use of taxpayer money, specifically criticizing the hiring of a communications firm to promote school expansion. Relvis suggested that existing district resources, such as high school students, could be leveraged to create promotional materials instead. She also raised safety concerns regarding the use of trailers for students and emphasized the need for transparency and appropriate allocation of taxpayer funds, given the district’s perceived high tax burden compared to others in the state.
In response to these comments, a board member acknowledged the importance of community feedback and expressed gratitude for the public’s engagement. The board discussed the inclusion process for special education and emphasized the need for understanding district procedures in this area. Acknowledgments were given to Rigs Distler and Company for their donation to the high school marching band.
Stephen Cappello
School Board Officials:
Laura Fitzwater, Ed Kenney, Katherine Bleistine, Michael Bramhall, Donna Marie Iacone, John Meeker, Christine Trampé
-
Meeting Type:
School Board
-
Committee:
-
Meeting Date:
09/25/2025
-
Recording Published:
09/25/2025
-
Duration:
66 Minutes
-
Notability Score:
Routine
Receive debriefs about local meetings in your inbox weekly:
-
State:
New Jersey
-
County:
Burlington County
-
Towns:
Cinnaminson
Recent Meetings Nearby:
- 12/04/2025
- 12/05/2025
- 77 Minutes
- 12/03/2025
- 12/03/2025
- 29 Minutes