One notable matter was the proposal for a new residential structure on Gillespie Avenue, which sought to replace a poorly designed house that had been a financial burden due to its inadequate layout and lack of historical character. The commission reviewed plans for a colonial revival-style home, emphasizing materials like cedar shingles and historically accurate moldings to align with the district’s late 19th to early 20th-century aesthetic. The proposed house features a cohesive design, maintaining historical symmetry through its four chimneys and carriage-type doors, while a summer entrance facilitates access to the backyard and pool. The commission expressed interest in the landscaping plan. After considering the architect’s presentation and the historical context, the commission acknowledged the application, planning to review further details in subsequent meetings.

Another topic was a proposed fence replacement on Fair Haven Road, adjacent to Memorial Park. The property owners, Dennis and Isabella, detailed their intention to replace a weathered cedar fence with a new six-foot cedar design, maintaining the original’s aesthetic. The commission noted jurisdictional ambiguity, as the fence borders public property, and suggested the owners engage with relevant borough authorities. The commission was inclined to approve the fence quickly to accommodate upcoming park events, provided there were no material concerns.

Simultaneously, the commission discussed an addition to the historic home on Fair Haven Road. The owners proposed extending the house, built in the 1890s, with a new master bedroom and laundry room, maintaining its historical integrity. The addition was designed not to disrupt the existing structure’s exterior or its view from the street, using materials like Hardy board for durability. Concerns about the lack of windows on the park side were addressed, noting constraints such as existing generators and street noise. The commission approved the addition, emphasizing the need to preserve the house’s historical character while accommodating modern living requirements.

The discussion then shifted to the Fish Chapel, Fair Haven’s sole historic landmark. The commission debated the color restoration, referencing two paint analyses from the Goldstein and BCA groups. The BCA report recommended painting the chapel green, reflecting its original color for several decades before it was painted white. The commission expressed urgency to decide before the chapel’s 250th anniversary celebrations, aligning with historical preservation principles. Although some members were apprehensive about adopting a specific shade, the commission leaned towards the BCA’s findings, proposing a motion to recommend painting the chapel green while allowing for flexibility should new information arise.

Public commentary supported the commission’s direction, with a resident advocating for the historical accuracy of the BCA’s color analysis. Another resident highlighted the need to address the chapel’s deteriorating chimney during the painting process, emphasizing its cultural implications. The commission planned to draft a memorandum reflecting the BCA’s findings and recognizing the chapel’s historical significance, particularly its connection to the African-American community.