Fair Haven’s Historic Preservation Commission Seeks Scientific Paint Analysis for Fisk Chapel’s Original Color
- Meeting Overview:
The Fair Haven Historic Preservation Commission, meeting to discuss preservation and restoration efforts, prioritized the need for a thorough scientific analysis of the original paint color of Fisk Chapel, an African-American church built in 1882. This focus on historical authenticity also extended to discussions about ongoing projects at Vics Centennial Hall and other historic sites within the district.
The commission’s primary concern revolved around Fisk Chapel’s paint color history, with debates centered on whether the chapel was originally white or green. An earlier study from the 1990s suggested the chapel had been green, but this research remains undocumented, raising questions about its validity. One participant noted the absence of access to this study and the need for clearer documentation. The commission emphasized the importance of providing an advisory opinion on the chapel’s color, despite not being the final decision-makers.
Frustration was expressed by a commission member over miscommunications with the council, particularly during a workshop where they were unable to present their findings or ask questions. Councilwoman Cole acknowledged these concerns, stressing the need for improved communication to ensure the commission’s input is recognized in future discussions.
In response, a unanimous vote was passed to collaborate with the historic association for a scientific paint analysis to supplement existing documentation. The commission expressed enthusiasm for this initiative, hoping it would reveal a variety of colors and enhance the building’s historical narrative. They also discussed funding possibilities, given the council’s initial rejection of financing another analysis. By independently funding the research, the commission aims to speed up the decision-making process and keep restoration projects on track.
The meeting also addressed the restoration of Vics Centennial Hall. The commission acknowledged their jurisdiction over the exterior, emphasizing the need to weigh in on restoration decisions without rushing the process. Discussions included mechanical, electrical, and architectural work, with concerns over prioritizing tasks raised by the commission. They resolved to gather more information and potentially fund further paint analysis independently, in light of previous research and funding limitations.
On another front, the commission initiated a digital archive project to preserve historical documents and images, which will be accessible via a new website. This project aims to enhance local historical engagement, particularly in K-8 education, with plans to incorporate Fair Haven’s history into school curricula.
Additionally, the commission discussed upcoming events, including a town festival “U Tide on Main Street” and the Century Home program. The festival aims to promote local shopping and community engagement, featuring attractions like Santa at the firehouse and free gift wrapping services. The Century Home program remains in development, with efforts to establish a dedicated online presence.
Public comments highlighted the absence of a dedicated budget for the commission, which operates on a volunteer basis. This prompted discussions on the importance of community engagement and the creation of an online repository to preserve and promote Fair Haven’s historical narrative.
Josh Halpern
Historic Preservation Commission Officials:
Arthur Pavluk, Jay Anderson, Patricia Drummond, Steven Heller, Joseph Schluter, Katy Frissora, Steven Smith, Victoria Forte, Elise Casey, Cole (Councilwoman), Kristen Hoey (Councilwoman)
-
Meeting Type:
Historic Preservation Commission
-
Committee:
-
Meeting Date:
10/28/2025
-
Recording Published:
10/29/2025
-
Duration:
87 Minutes
-
Notability Score:
Routine
Receive debriefs about local meetings in your inbox weekly:
-
State:
New Jersey
-
County:
Monmouth County
-
Towns:
Fair Haven
Recent Meetings Nearby:
- 12/03/2025
- 12/03/2025
- 29 Minutes
- 12/03/2025
- 12/03/2025
- 204 Minutes
- 12/03/2025
- 12/03/2025
- 49 Minutes