0:00The most contentious topic involved the application by Maria Hickey Associates, who sought permission to install hay bales and conduct dune nourishment on Wheeling Avenue. The proposed method aimed to mitigate the severe erosion caused by winter storms at the mouth of Falmouth Harbor. Maria Hickey articulated the challenges faced, noting that strong storms have resulted in significant dune erosion, threatening the stability of the property. Hickey advocated for the installation of hay bales, which she claimed had successfully protected neighboring properties from similar erosion.

However, the commission expressed reservations about the effectiveness of hay bales. Staff members shared observations of past instances where hay bales led to further damage rather than protection. Concerns were raised about their practicality, especially in a V-zone where strong waves could potentially wash over them. The commission deliberated on whether the hay bales should be approved, with Vice Chairman Courtney Bird highlighting the need for a thorough discussion before reaching a decision.

Hickey defended her proposal by presenting evidence of past successes with hay bales, emphasizing that without them, a substantial portion of the dunes could be lost. She provided photographs to support her claims, although technical difficulties prevented her from sharing them during the meeting. Despite her efforts, the commission remained divided, with some members questioning the long-term viability of hay bales and suggesting alternative erosion control methods, such as snow fencing.

The commission ultimately decided to split the application discussion into two parts, approving the work proposed but excluding the use of hay bales. This decision was influenced by the lack of confirmed resource area boundaries and skepticism about the hay bales’ utility in the given conditions.

38:06Another topic was the proposal for a property on Poid Street, submitted by the Philip P. Scones Revocable Trust. The project involved the removal of an existing shed and deck, with plans for two additions. Tim Santos, representing the trust, outlined the proposal. The commission expressed concerns about the proximity of the proposed additions to the salt marsh, emphasizing potential risks related to future erosion and sea-level rise. Members suggested elevating the structure on pilings.

58:04Discussion also turned to a project on Nascet Road, which involved raising an existing dwelling and constructing a new home, garage, and pool. The commission reviewed the plans, focusing on compliance with velocity zone building standards, including the use of piles for the new structure. The landscape architect proposed native plantings as mitigation, sparking debates about the choice of lower shrubs versus taller plants.

1:52:46Another agenda item involved the reconstruction of a licensed pier on Qued Harbor Road. The deteriorating structure needed replacement due to failed fastenings and corroded timbers. The commission supported the proposal to rebuild the pier using non-treated materials and stainless steel fastenings, emphasizing the importance of sustainable practices in maintaining harbor infrastructure.

0:00The meeting also addressed enforcement orders for unpermitted activities, including vegetation removal and construction without permits. These cases were continued to future dates, with the commission emphasizing the necessity of adhering to regulatory requirements.