Garwood Borough Council Faces Controversy Over Lawsuit Against Affordable Housing Mandates
- Meeting Overview:
The Garwood Borough Council meeting brought attention to the borough’s involvement in a multi-municipality lawsuit contesting state-mandated affordable housing requirements. The council also honored community members, reviewed ongoing projects, and discussed public safety measures, including drones and health product recalls.
During the council meeting, A discussion arose concerning Garwood’s participation in a lawsuit against New Jersey’s affordable housing mandates. A council member criticized the borough’s involvement, arguing that it was tantamount to “lighting tax money on fire” due to the lawsuit’s perceived weak arguments and the courts’ consistent support for the constitutionality of affordable housing laws. They emphasized the need for affordable housing across New Jersey and urged a focus on responsible development rather than legal action. This sentiment highlighted a significant divide within the council regarding the borough’s strategy to address housing needs.
In a positive turn, the council celebrated two significant milestones in the community. Mayor Jen Blumenstock presented the Community Spirit Award to John Nolan for his nine years of service on the Garwood Public Library Board of Trustees. The mayor commended Nolan for his dedication and contributions, including his military service during the Cuban Missile Crisis and his work in broadcasting. Nolan expressed gratitude for the support from past mayors and library director Maryann Duffy, acknowledging the collaborative efforts that characterized his tenure. In recognition, he received a drawing of the library from Bill Connelly.
Additionally, the council marked the 85th anniversary of the Garwood First Aid Squad, acknowledging its commitment since 1939. The squad has responded to over 300 calls annually and participates in community events. A squad representative expressed gratitude for the recognition and emphasized their ongoing dedication to public safety and collaboration with local emergency services.
The meeting also addressed administrative updates. Renovations to office flooring were near completion, though some offices, including the court, faced temporary closures due to ongoing construction. Updates were provided on a new shade structure at the Athletic Field Complex, expected to finish soon. Efforts were underway to finalize several grant proposals aimed at enhancing community services and events, credited to the leadership of the Recreation Director. The council also concluded its tree planting initiatives for the year, having fully utilized funds from the Greening Union County Grant.
Public safety discussions extended to drone sightings in New Jersey. Mayor Blumenstock attended meetings with the FAA, FBI, and Homeland Security to address concerns about unidentifiable drones. While many sightings were traceable, the mayor highlighted efforts to secure advanced federal technology to tackle the issue. Residents were cautioned against using personal drones or lasers due to aircraft safety risks.
The council also tackled a lawsuit challenging affordable housing requirements, with a council member voicing strong opposition to Garwood’s participation. They argued the lawsuit was wasteful and advocated focusing on addressing housing needs through development rather than litigation. This marked a notable division among council members on handling affordable housing challenges.
Council discussions covered various community updates. The Fire Department’s report noted that a fire truck was back in service after maintenance, with ongoing training sessions on water rescue and hazardous materials. The Public Works Department focused on leaf cleanup, snow removal preparations, and assembling recreation department basketball hoops. The police committee reported positive feedback on the Power Engage system, enabling public insights on police interactions, and promising results from the Park Mobile program with over 7,000 transactions.
Community engagement activities included a holiday house decorating contest extension and events like the menorah lighting. The library announced upcoming programs, such as a New Year celebration for children and crafting activities for all ages, highlighting the strong community involvement.
The meeting touched on other topics like health and safety recalls. Councilman Foley relayed information about a nationwide FDA recall on products containing tan nepe and Diamond shrooms, known for posing health risks. The Board of Health conducted inspections in Garwood, finding no recalled products but ensuring businesses were informed. Foley planned to collaborate with the municipal Alliance to educate parents on these products, with proposals to be reviewed by the Community Development Committee next year.
Public comments featured congratulations for the Garwood First Aid Squad’s 85 years and gratitude to the Fire Department for its Santa run. Bruce Patterson, a public attendee, questioned specific resolutions, seeking clarity on resolution 24201 related to personnel matters and a grant application for senior social service programs. Council members clarified these resolutions, emphasizing that the affordable housing lawsuit discussions involved legislative pressure rather than court reliance.
Jen Blumenstock
City Council Officials:
Karina Boto (Councilwoman), Sean Foley (Councilman), Vincent Kearney (Council President), Marc Lazarow (Councilman), Clarissa Nolde (Councilwoman), Kimberly Salmon (Councilwoman)
-
Meeting Type:
City Council
-
Committee:
-
Meeting Date:
12/19/2024
-
Recording Published:
12/19/2024
-
Duration:
57 Minutes
-
Notability Score:
Noteworthy
Receive debriefs about local meetings in your inbox weekly:
-
State:
New Jersey
-
County:
Union County
-
Towns:
Garwood
Recent Meetings Nearby:
- 12/12/2025
- 34 Minutes
- 12/12/2025
- 12/12/2025
- 64 Minutes
- 12/11/2025
- 12/11/2025
- 71 Minutes