The meeting kicked off with the review of application 557 on Stewart Road, a non-contributing property in the Short Hills Park historic district. The applicant, John Gazman, proposed a stone driveway finish, widened portico, and expanded patio and garage. The commission, after a discussion around zoning adjustments and the driveway width, approved the application.

Meanwhile, a project on Chestnut Street drew attention and debate. Amar Kumar and N. Singh, the property owners, alongside their architect, Douglas Miller, presented plans for exterior improvements, including a new two-story addition with an attached garage and driveway, a rear upper deck, and landscape modifications. The proposition aimed to modernize the house while preserving its historic character.

However, the proposal sparked opposition from Daniel and Eva Weinstein, owners of the neighboring property on Chestnut Street. They highlighted potential issues, such as increased water runoff from the proposed driveway and loss of privacy due to tree removal. They also expressed concerns about the potential impact on the neighborhood’s overall character. In response, Mr. Singh outlined the measures taken to address these concerns, including clearing overgrown vegetation, implementing water runoff solutions, and planning for replacement trees.

The Historical Preservation Board, led by Alison Canfield, engaged in a discussion regarding the project, focusing on the project’s compliance with town regulations and potential need for variances. The board members probed the specifics of front yard setback requirements and implications of the proposed design. The dialogue emphasized the importance of balancing preservation considerations with the property owners’ interests and the neighborhood’s character.

In another significant item, an applicant requested clarity on a front yard setback definition, voicing concerns about a recent ordinance change that could require many houses with additions to seek variances. After discussions, the board approved the application, with some members supporting the addition of a garage as consistent with town regulations.

The board also reviewed a proposal for a new single-family residence in the Short Hills Park historic district by Bernardine W. After reviewing minor changes to the original plan and receiving a positive recommendation from the town’s consultant, David Barton, the board approved the application.