Islamorada Council Deadlocked Over Vacant Seat Appointment Amid Public Debate

In a recent Islamorada Village Council meeting, the central focus was the contentious process of appointing a new council member to fill a vacancy. The council faced a deadlock, with votes repeatedly split between candidates Greg Dully and Anna Richards. Public comments emphasized concerns over transparency, the need for a democratic process, and potential conflicts of interest, culminating in a decision to postpone the appointment until March.

0:28The meeting unfolded with debate over the process for filling the vacant council seat left by former council member Buddy Pender. Public input was robust, with various community members expressing their opinions on the appropriate candidate for the position. Van Cadenhead, a long-time resident, highlighted the importance of selecting someone who genuinely understands the community’s needs, citing concerns over “unbridled growth” and advocating for environmental conservation. Cadenhead, who had previously campaigned for the position, was supported by some residents who argued for appointing a candidate with established voter backing.

39:34Joe Wishm echoed this sentiment, stating that those who had previously run for the council should be prioritized for the appointment. Wishm pointed out that the public had already shown support for candidates like Cadenhead and Richards in past elections.

The council’s deliberations were marked by a notable lack of consensus. Initial votes on appointing Dully ended in a tie, with Vice Mayor Don Horton and Mayor Sharon Mahoney opposing the motion. This impasse led to further public comments, where concerns about the fairness of the process and potential conflicts of interest were voiced. One individual questioned the neutrality of council members who had past business dealings with candidates, emphasizing the need for transparency and ethical decision-making.

57:42Amidst these discussions, the council considered alternative methods for breaking the deadlock, including a light-hearted suggestion of a coin toss, which was ultimately dismissed. Despite these challenges, the council remained committed to finding a resolution that would align with the community’s values and needs.

3:05:53Adding to the complexity, the council also addressed the broader implications of the appointment process, including the potential for legal repercussions if they failed to appoint a candidate within the 30-day period mandated by the village charter. The village attorney clarified that while missing this deadline might lead to a citizen lawsuit, there were no financial penalties associated with the delay.

2:30:29As the meeting progressed, the council shifted its attention to the search for an interim village manager, with Allan Cohen emerging as a potential candidate. Cohen, who attended the meeting, was presented as a viable option due to his extensive experience in both public and private sectors. However, concerns about his non-local status and the logistics of his potential commute were raised. Despite these issues, the motion to negotiate Cohen’s appointment passed unanimously, with the council planning to revisit the discussion at the next meeting.

Note: This meeting summary was generated by AI, which can occasionally misspell names, misattribute actions, and state inaccuracies. This summary is intended to be a starting point and you should review the meeting record linked above before acting on anything you read. If we got something wrong, let us know. We’re working every day to improve our process in pursuit of universal local government transparency.

Receive debriefs about local meetings in your inbox weekly:

Trending meetings
across the country: