The most critical discussion revolved around the Founders Park boat ramp, where the council evaluated the feasibility of constructing new boat ramps or enhancing existing ones to support local fishing guides. The current ramp’s proximity to dense mangroves and seagrass posed environmental challenges, complicating new installations due to regulations for sites classified as Outstanding Florida Waters. The potential costs of mitigating environmental impacts, particularly the loss of seagrass and mangroves, were estimated to reach approximately $50,000. As a result, the council weighed these costs against the estimated $600,000 to $700,000 needed for construction.

Alternative locations, like the Blackwood Drive boat ramp, were considered but faced practical limitations such as lack of dockage and flat terrain, deeming them unsuitable for guides. The council recognized the need for further exploration of alternative options and the importance of balancing environmental impacts with community benefits.

Public input underscored the urgency of addressing these ramp issues. Richard Black, speaking for the Florida Keys Fishing Guides Association, advocated for additional public ramps to counteract the privatization trend that limits access for guides. He emphasized the potential community and environmental benefits of a new ramp.

Captain Ted Bendo, a local skiff guide, echoed these sentiments, stressing the economic contributions of fishing tourism and questioning the adequacy of current facilities in Islamorada, known as the “sport fishing capital of the world.” He proposed that the village could generate revenue through launch fees, advocating for public ownership of marinas to ensure equitable access.

The council’s deliberations also touched on the financial implications of constructing new ramps, with some members expressing skepticism about the village bearing the full cost. They suggested collaborative approaches to funding, acknowledging the high costs of dredging and seagrass mitigation. The conversation revealed a complex interplay of community interests, economic considerations, and environmental responsibilities, with the council leaning towards improving existing facilities as an initial step.

In other business, the council addressed the controversial canal air curtain project, designed to mitigate aquatic vegetation growth. The project faced opposition from residents like Samantha Sanchez, who argued that the system would offer little benefit to those living at the canal’s mouth while imposing unwanted costs. A motion to deny the project was passed, meaning residents would need to independently fund the initiative if desired.

Further, the council reviewed updates to the personnel policy manual, reflecting regulatory changes and introducing new incentives for professional development. Other agenda items included the approval of a new fire truck purchase and discussions on village property management.