Jackson Zoning Board Deliberates on Swanborn LLC Subdivision and Tent Use for Shul Amid Safety Concerns
- Meeting Overview:
In a recent Jackson Zoning Board meeting, discussions were dominated by Swanborn LLC’s application for subdivision changes and the controversial use of a tent as a temporary shul.
19:17The most notable discussion centered around Swanborn LLC’s proposal to amend its subdivision plan to incorporate updated stormwater management requirements. Graham McFarland, representing the applicant, detailed the changes including the introduction of small-scale infiltration basins to meet new green infrastructure mandates. An alteration of the project’s access points was a significant highlight, notably the removal of a proposed Denton Lane access, replaced with a cul-de-sac at the roadway’s end. This adjustment raised safety and accessibility concerns, particularly regarding emergency vehicle access. The board debated the type and necessity of fencing around these basins, considering liability and safety issues. McFarland advocated for chain-link fencing due to its durability, though shrubbery as an alternative was also discussed. The basins, shallow and with small footprints, were to be managed by a Homeowners Association, not the municipality, adding another layer of consideration regarding maintenance and safety.
01:21:46Further complicating the discussion was the need for emergency access routes, a concern raised due to the project’s compliance with Residential Site Improvement Standards (RSIS) but requiring board input on emergency accessibility. The board members expressed varied opinions, weighing safety against aesthetic considerations and maintenance responsibilities. The need for a comprehensive approach to ensure safety, particularly for families with young children near the basins, was emphasized.
02:57:53In addition to Swanborn LLC’s proposal, attention was given to a zoning application involving a tent used as a synagogue and a wrestling school on the same property. This issue brought forth discussion over zoning compliance and safety concerns. The tent, initially erected during the COVID-19 pandemic as a temporary measure for a growing congregation, faced scrutiny due to its illegal status without proper permits or inspections. The board discussed the safety implications of the tent, especially with large gatherings anticipated.
01:01:14The applicant argued for the tent’s necessity, highlighting its role in accommodating community worship needs and the special circumstances during its erection. However, there were strong voices opposing its continued use without adherence to zoning laws, emphasizing the importance of regulatory compliance to avoid setting a precedent for unapproved structures.
50:12The wrestling school, on the other hand, operated under a 2009 variance for home occupation use, which had lapsed when the property changed hands. The board deliberated on whether the school could continue operating without a site plan, given its classification as a quasi-public or private recreational use. Concerns were raised about the appropriateness of granting variances without detailed site plans, as well as procedural oversight failures that allowed the school to operate without necessary township permits.
Amid these discussions, the board explored the possibility of separating the tent and the wrestling school applications to address the complexities surrounding each. There was a consensus on the need for clear resolutions to ensure zoning compliance while considering community needs and historical context.
Michael Reina
Zoning Board Officials:
Lynne Bradley, Kenneth Bressi, Shira Parnes, Robert Hudak, Moshe Heiman, Sheldon Hofstein, Chrystabel Rosal, Carlos V. Martins, Jason Such, Jeffrey Purpuro (Zoning Officer), Gina Tumolo (Assistant Zoning Officer), Dawn D’Agostino (Zoning Board Clerk), Ryan Murphy (Attorney), Mark Rohmeyer (Engineer), Ernie Peters (Traffic Engineer)
-
Meeting Type:
Zoning Board
-
Committee:
-
Meeting Date:
06/18/2025
-
Recording Published:
06/18/2025
-
Duration:
267 Minutes
-
Notability Score:
Routine
Receive debriefs about local meetings in your inbox weekly:
-
State:
New Jersey
-
County:
Ocean County
-
Towns:
Jackson
Recent Meetings Nearby:
- 07/16/2025
- 07/16/2025
- 104 Minutes
- 07/16/2025
- 12 Minutes
- 07/16/2025
- 07/17/2025
- 78 Minutes