Long Hill Town Council Faces Tension Over Police Promotion Process Changes

The recent Long Hill Town Council meeting addressed several issues, with the most pressing being the proposed changes to the police department’s promotion process. The introduction of a written examination for police promotions sparked considerable debate, highlighting concerns regarding transparency, practicality, and the impact on officers’ duties. The meeting also recognized local achievements and discussed community safety, health initiatives, and infrastructure concerns.

36:29The council meeting’s primary focus was the proposed ordinance regarding the police department’s promotion process, specifically the introduction of a written examination for sergeants. Detective Geressie, representing the Police Benevolent Association (PBA), conveyed strong opposition to this change, arguing that it could negatively affect the department’s integrity and effectiveness. The PBA had previously expressed these concerns in a March 12 meeting, emphasizing that the written exam would not accurately assess essential practical skills and judgment.

29:32Despite some discussions with the council, the PBA felt blindsided by the introduction of a new ordinance on May 28, which still included the controversial written exam. The PBA criticized the lack of prior notification about these changes, raising issues about communication and transparency within the township’s leadership. The detective highlighted that officers eligible for promotion already face challenges balancing work and personal life, and an added written test would increase stress and detract from their primary responsibilities.

The debate continued with contrasting views from council members. Some supported the written examination, arguing that certain knowledge could only be assessed through this method, while others acknowledged the current sergeants’ performance without having undergone such testing. The PBA maintained that the existing promotion system, proven effective over time, should not be altered, particularly given the significant investments in understanding the department’s needs, none of which recommended implementing written exams.

51:56In light of these concerns, a motion was made to table the discussion for further examination, particularly focusing on financial implications and the necessity of the proposed examination format. The council expressed a desire for continued dialogue with all stakeholders, including the PBA, to address specific concerns comprehensively.

03:25Beyond the contentious police promotion discussions, the meeting celebrated local achievements, starting with a presentation honoring the Central School girls’ softball team for winning the Central Jersey Athletic Association tournament. The mayor commended the team’s resilience in overcoming a three-run deficit to win in extra innings, highlighting the contributions of eighth graders Riley Hall, Angelina Store, Bella Wiggins, and Orla Butler.

06:30The meeting also included a swearing-in ceremony for three new police officers: Tyler Lombardo, Christopher J. Deviasi, and Nina Tanton. Each officer’s background was introduced, followed by their oath of office.

27:53Additionally, the council received a report from the Board of Health, announcing upcoming health programs, including a Type 2 diabetes prevention program and several blood pressure screening clinics. The council also discussed the role of the Community Emergency Response Team (CERT), which has contributed to maintaining safety and facilitating town events.

01:23:20Infrastructure and safety were other topics, with discussions on sidewalk maintenance and mosquito control measures. Concerns were raised about the township’s unusual responsibility for sidewalk upkeep, prompting calls for a reevaluation of policies to promote a walkable community in light of planned park developments. The Morris County Mosquito Commission’s upcoming spraying operations were also announced, addressing concerns about mosquito populations.

01:16:28The meeting concluded with public comments, including a suggestion for an ordinance regarding electric bikes and a proposal to regulate flags on town property. The council expressed differing views on the necessity of such regulations, emphasizing the importance of maintaining flexibility for future decisions.

Note: This meeting summary was generated by AI, which can occasionally misspell names, misattribute actions, and state inaccuracies. This summary is intended to be a starting point and you should review the meeting record linked above before acting on anything you read. If we got something wrong, let us know. We’re working every day to improve our process in pursuit of universal local government transparency.

Receive debriefs about local meetings in your inbox weekly:

is discussed during:
in these locations: