Marlboro School Board Faces Tensions Over Civility and Public Engagement Amid Leadership Changes
- Meeting Overview:
The recent Marlboro School Board meeting was marked by discussions over board member civility, public engagement, and leadership dynamics.
A significant portion of the meeting focused on a proposed resolution aimed at fostering civility and decorum among board members, especially in digital and public forums. The resolution intended to establish clear standards for conduct and emphasize the importance of respectful communication, both in physical settings and online. However, this proposal sparked considerable debate among board members, with disagreements centering on the necessity and timing of the resolution. Some members expressed concerns that the resolution, while well-intentioned, might not translate into actionable changes. They argued that the board should naturally uphold respectful conduct without requiring formal resolutions. Others stressed the urgency of adopting the resolution to address ongoing issues of decorum and accountability within the board.
The discussion around the resolution also highlighted a broader tension regarding the board’s responsiveness to community input. A board member noted the lack of replies to over 300 emails from constituents, criticizing the board president’s handling of communication and suggesting a disconnect between the board and the community it serves. This sentiment was echoed by a community member who voiced dissatisfaction with the board’s leadership, emphasizing a need for improved engagement and transparency.
In the context of these tensions, the meeting also addressed the departures of board members Annette Siewert and Valentina Mendez, whose resignations were met with expressions of gratitude for their service. Community members and fellow board members acknowledged Siewert and Mendez’s contributions, particularly their efforts to advocate for parental rights and transparency in education. Their departure was seen as a significant transition for the board, with calls for remaining members to foster a more respectful and united approach moving forward.
Public comments further underscored the community’s concerns about board leadership and civility. Speakers criticized the board’s handling of specific incidents, with one individual questioning the lack of an apology for a prior situation that had impacted community relations. Additionally, concerns were raised about the board’s role in addressing harassment and bullying, both within the board and the broader district.
Another topic of discussion was the board’s approach to social media engagement. The resolution on civility included provisions related to digital interactions, prompting debate about the extent to which board members should participate in online discussions. Some members argued that restrictions on social media engagement could hinder communication and outreach efforts, while others emphasized the need for maintaining respectful and constructive discourse, even in digital spaces.
In addition to these discussions, the meeting addressed budgetary challenges and personnel matters. The district’s financial adviser provided an update on the bond sale for HVAC upgrades, outlining the favorable credit rating and borrowing terms secured for the project. Budget discussions also highlighted the district’s ongoing financial pressures, particularly concerning rising health benefit costs and state funding formulas.
Personnel updates included the acknowledgment of retirements and new hires, with particular recognition given to Narin Favaluro for her 25 years of service. The board expressed appreciation for her contributions, emphasizing the impact of dedicated staff on the district’s success.
As the meeting concluded, there was a motion to adjourn to an executive session to discuss legal and personnel matters, with a request for enhanced security measures during the session. This motion underscored the ongoing concerns about safety and the need for a secure environment for board discussions.
Michael Ballone
School Board Officials:
Brian Cohen, Chad Hyett, Danielle Bellomo, Jenna Corraro, Aditi Gandhi, Michael Lilonsky, Valentina Mendez, Susanne Miskiewicz, Annette Siewert, Vincent Caravello (District’s Custodian of Records), Dana Tardio (District Anti-Bullying Coordinator)
-
Meeting Type:
School Board
-
Committee:
-
Meeting Date:
12/16/2025
-
Recording Published:
12/16/2025
-
Duration:
274 Minutes
-
Notability Score:
Routine
Receive debriefs about local meetings in your inbox weekly:
-
State:
New Jersey
-
County:
Monmouth County
-
Towns:
Marlboro
Recent Meetings Nearby:
- 12/18/2025
- 12/19/2025
- 33 Minutes
- 12/18/2025
- 12/19/2025
- 45 Minutes
- 12/18/2025
- 12/19/2025
- 128 Minutes