The meeting’s most issue involved the proposed streetlighting changes on West Avenue. Board members debated the adoption of modern lighting fixtures to replace existing outdated designs, which some described as reminiscent of “Little House on the Prairie.” There was a strong push for lighting that aligns with Miami Beach’s architectural style, with calls to explore more contemporary options such as “saucer” lights. These proposed changes reflect a broader urban planning objective to enhance the city’s visual consistency and safety. Concerns about maintenance and supply logistics for new lighting types were also raised.

As part of a larger effort to modernize infrastructure, the board unanimously passed a motion recommending that future streetlight designs consider the board’s input.

Another topic was the proposed design for a new four-story multifamily building on Hibiscus Island. The applicant sought waivers and variances due to the narrow lot, with discussions centering on open space requirements and building height. The board generally supported the design but emphasized the need for compliance with city codes and consideration of the surrounding environment. One board member praised the design’s architectural features but called for permeable materials for the driveway to address potential flooding issues. The applicant’s request to raise the first-floor elevation for resilience was also scrutinized, with the board considering the implications for neighborhood aesthetics.

The meeting also saw concerns from residents about deviations from approved plans in ongoing construction projects. Participants expressed frustration over potential violations, such as unauthorized height increases and encroachments into setbacks. The board discussed the necessity of as-built surveys and compliance checks to ensure constructions align with approved specifications.

A recurring theme throughout the meeting was the balance between modern design aspirations and maintaining neighborhood character. The board examined a proposal for a new residence on Still Water Drive, emphasizing the need for the design to fit within the existing architectural context. The proposal included contemporary elements such as vertical wood louvers and extensive glazing, but staff recommended height reductions to meet anticipated zoning limits. The board deliberated on achieving a design that accommodates rising sea levels while respecting the scale of surrounding homes.

The board also considered a proposal for a generator installation at a water booster station on Terminal Island. Despite the necessity of the generator for community resilience, board members stressed the need for it to blend aesthetically with the environment. The discussion pointed to a broader concern about integrating essential infrastructure into the urban landscape without compromising the city’s visual appeal.