Critics argued that the valuation failed to consider the land’s development potential, including the capacity for luxury condos and significant retail space. A speaker noted that the transaction would allow the developer, BH3 Marramac, to benefit disproportionately, capturing the entire increase in value from the land. Concerns were raised about the city trading long-term rental income for an upfront payment.

Several residents and city officials expressed their opposition, calling for a deferral of the vote to allow further negotiations and the engagement of a real estate advisory firm to ensure a fair deal. Despite these calls, the motion to approve the sale with updated documents passed by a 4-1 vote.

In addition to the Watson Island issue, the meeting addressed various other topics, including the city’s approach to addressing crime and housing challenges in the Southwest 8th Street area. One commissioner questioned the allocation of $4 million intended for purchasing motels as a solution to crime and prostitution issues in the area.

The commission also debated the future site of a new police and fire headquarters, with the Freedom Park location emerging as a preferred option due to its potential for generating property tax revenue. The decision involved weighing the costs and benefits of different sites, with considerations around traffic implications, community impact, and funding. Commissioners emphasized the need for a comprehensive traffic study and community feedback before finalizing the decision.

Public safety and community services were recurring themes throughout the meeting, with various speakers advocating for initiatives addressing homelessness and supporting local community programs. The Downtown Neighbors Alliance supported a resolution to tackle homelessness in downtown Miami, urging responsible financial management and the effective use of Bayfront Park Trust funds for these services.

Further discussions included the approval of several zoning amendments and funding allocations by the Community Redevelopment Agency, focusing on affordable housing and community development projects. The CRA approved grants for housing projects and community venues.

The meeting also featured recognitions of local organizations and individuals for their contributions to the community. The Miami Black Arts Workshop and the Greater Miami Service Corps were acknowledged for their roles in promoting the arts and supporting youth development, respectively. These recognitions highlighted the city’s appreciation for cultural and social contributions that enhance community life.