Middletown School Board Faces Backlash Over Mental Health Support Cuts
- Meeting Overview:
In a recent Middletown School Board meeting, discussions arose regarding the decision to eliminate the tier three Effective School Solutions (ESS) program, designed to aid at-risk middle school students with social and emotional needs. This decision sparked significant concern among parents, who fear the negative implications for student support and teacher workload. Additionally, the Board addressed the proposed school closure policy, staffing, and transparency issues within district operations.
01:10:13The termination of the ESS program, which has been a cornerstone of support for students dealing with complex behavioral issues, was a focal point of the meeting. A parent, Erica Lucesy, voiced strong objections to the cut, explaining that the program had drastically reduced crisis meetings and improved her daughter’s schooling experience. It allowed teachers to concentrate on educational objectives rather than being overwhelmed by behavioral management.
Lucesy raised questions about the district’s plan to hire an in-house clinician as a replacement for the ESS program. She expressed concerns over accountability, training, and whether this new clinician would follow an evidence-based curriculum similar to ESS. The parent highlighted the risks associated with the district’s ability to fill and maintain this position, emphasizing potential gaps in support should the clinician leave or require extended leave.
01:22:25Financial concerns regarding the ESS program were also discussed. The Board noted that the contract had grown to $1.6 million for just 74 students, sparking a debate about cost-effectiveness. Although a reduction to $1.1 million for approximately 70 students had been made, the administration emphasized the need for a more fiscally responsible solution. It was acknowledged that while mental health support is crucial, it is not mandated by law, prompting a reevaluation of how these services are delivered.
The Board aims to employ clinicians with extensive clinical backgrounds, paralleling the services formerly provided by ESS. This plan is intended to broaden access to mental health resources beyond those with Individualized Education Programs (IEPs), recognizing a wider need for these services among the student population.
01:45:01In other matters, the Board discussed the long-term implications of the proposed school closure policy. Aligning with the district’s Long Range Facility Plan, the policy requires a feasibility study prioritizing the closures’ benefits beyond financial efficiencies. Concerns were raised about the potential reassignment of students leading to unlawful segregation.
01:02:33Public comments reflected dissatisfaction with the transparency of district operations, particularly regarding the shared services committee and the administration’s communication with the community. The need for clear, open dialogue was emphasized, with suggestions for more interactive public comment sessions during board meetings.
59:10The financial implications of police presence at board meetings were also addressed. A suggestion was made to revisit shared costs with the mayor to alleviate the district’s financial challenges. There was a call for the board to engage more directly with the public during comments, as current protocols seemed to limit meaningful interaction.
01:41:46Another topic was the recognition of retiring staff member, Mrs. Harrington. Members expressed gratitude for her years of service and impact on the student body, acknowledging the challenges her departure would bring. Applause followed her acknowledgment, underscoring her positive influence over the years.
38:32The meeting additionally covered updates on the Champions Program for before and after school care. Plans for registration and an open house were discussed.
01:43:20A recurring issue with bees at Bayview Elementary School was reported, with ongoing efforts to manage the situation safely. Despite multiple visits from exterminators, the problem persists, prompting plans for long-term irrigation solutions to deter the bees.
In new business, the Board addressed community concerns about a proposed crematorium at Fairview Cemetery. A draft letter opposing its proximity to neighborhoods and schools was presented, with board members showing support for the motion.
Jessica Alfone
School Board Officials:
Frank Capone, Jacqueline Tobacco, Leonora Caminiti, Joseph Fitzgerald, Joan Minnuies, Caterina Skalaski, Mark Soporowski, Gary Tulp, Deborah Wright
-
Meeting Type:
School Board
-
Committee:
-
Meeting Date:
05/20/2025
-
Recording Published:
05/20/2025
-
Duration:
112 Minutes
-
Notability Score:
Routine
Receive debriefs about local meetings in your inbox weekly:
-
State:
New Jersey
-
County:
Monmouth County
-
Towns:
Middletown
Recent Meetings Nearby:
- 06/10/2025
- 06/10/2025
- 258 Minutes
- 06/10/2025
- 06/10/2025
- 13 Minutes
- 06/09/2025
- 06/09/2025
- 76 Minutes