The most notable issue addressed during the meeting was the council’s decision to approve Ordinance 24553, amending the borough’s water rates. The ordinance passed with a majority vote, although some members expressed dissatisfaction with the changes. The new regulations lowered the minimum water usage threshold from 7,500 gallons to 5,400 gallons, which one council member criticized as unfairly penalizing low water users and conservationists, including seniors and single residents. They emphasized that the ordinance effectively punishes those who conserve water, a sentiment echoed by another council member concerned about the broader impact of rising costs on residents amidst inflation. This debate highlighted the ongoing challenge of balancing fiscal responsibility with equitable billing practices.

Following the water rate discussion, the council moved to approve Ordinance 24554, which addressed amendments to sewer use charges. The mayor expressed frustration over the high sewer costs, which surpassed those for water, citing the constraints of an existing agreement with New Brunswick. These sentiments underscored the financial pressures faced by the borough as it navigates contractual obligations and seeks to manage utility costs.

Amid these discussions, a significant tax liability concerning a 23-acre site on Fort Avenue was brought to light. A council member reported an outstanding tax debt exceeding $6 million, which had yet to be paid. This situation was framed as part of a broader issue of uncollected taxes and missed revenue opportunities, with the council member stressing the financial burden placed on Milltown’s residents. They advocated for addressing these longstanding fiscal challenges, emphasizing the necessity of finding solutions to alleviate the stress on the community.

The meeting also delved into community concerns over program fee disparities. Margaret O’Donnell, representing the Milltown women’s volleyball program, addressed the council regarding a fee inequality between the women’s and men’s recreational programs. O’Donnell highlighted that the women’s program, which ran for 12 weeks, was priced the same as the men’s 18-week basketball program, despite the difference in duration. She urged the council to re-evaluate the pricing structure to ensure equity, citing the historical context of Title IX and the ongoing efforts to achieve fairness in sports programs.

In addition to these financial and community-focused discussions, the council addressed several administrative matters. Business Administrator Bre Car provided an update on the borough’s bond anticipation notes for 2024, noting a favorable bidding outcome that resulted in bonding $3.4 million to support road and water improvements, an electric vehicle purchase, and other capital projects. The Borough Clerk reminded residents of upcoming dog license renewals, emphasizing rabies vaccination requirements and providing information on free clinics in Middlesex County.

During the meeting, commendations were given to Sergeant Michael Dennis and Officer Michael McCabe for their community policing efforts and holiday initiatives aimed at spreading cheer among local families. The council and mayor also expressed gratitude towards the Milltown Fire Department and Rescue Squad for their participation in holiday activities.

As the meeting progressed, council members addressed old and new business items, with one member voicing concerns over a seven-month “mediation” investigation, criticizing the expenditure of taxpayer funds and vowing to oppose similar future costs. The public comment portion allowed residents to express concerns about water quality and the new alert notification system, as well as to extend holiday greetings and acknowledge the contributions of long-serving council members.