17:16The MPHA and several residents expressed concerns that a historic designation could hinder essential investments needed to address Glendale’s significant capital backlog of $22 million. This backlog is disproportionate, given that Glendale comprises less than 3% of the MPHA’s housing portfolio yet represents 8% of its total backlog. The MPHA emphasized the need for substantial redevelopment to meet the current and future needs of Glendale’s predominantly Black and African American residents. They argued that a historic designation would confine the community to outdated housing and perpetuate a cycle of segregation and disinvestment. The MPHA assured residents that redevelopment plans would not displace them against their will and highlighted a history of maintaining affordability during similar transitions.

04:41The commission engaged in a discussion about the assessment of Glendale’s historic integrity. The original flat roofs and brick veneer of the buildings have been altered over time, affecting the site’s historic integrity. Despite this, Glendale holds cultural and social significance as an early affordable housing project. The commission’s staff recommended denying the local historic designation based on these alterations. However, the discussions revealed a broader tension between preserving the architectural history and addressing the needs of current residents.

41:29Residents’ testimonies during the public comments section revealed a spectrum of opinions. Many shared personal stories highlighting Glendale’s role as a safe haven and the support they received from MPHA. Shaneen, a long-time resident, described Glendale as a vital stepping stone for families, while others like Patricia Lee Woods and Kantrell Motley praised the community’s safety and amenities. Concerns about misinformation regarding the historic designation were prevalent, with some residents fearing it could lead to unwanted redevelopment.

01:12:31Conversely, some community members and advocates, including those involved in the resident-led petition for historic designation, emphasized Glendale’s historical importance. Latow Joseph, co-founder of the Public Housing Coalition, clarified that residents were supportive of the designation, believing it would preserve Glendale’s unique history within Minneapolis. Jerain Cuff and others highlighted the potential for growth and development within the community, advocating for preservation efforts that align with residents’ needs.

The commission heard arguments that maintaining Glendale’s historical designation could complicate investment and modernization efforts, potentially impacting the quality of life for current residents. The MPHA’s representatives underscored the need for larger homes and improved living conditions, citing a waiting list of 4,300 families seeking adequate housing solutions. They argued that historic preservation focuses on appearance rather than the functional use of the buildings, complicating necessary updates and improvements.