North Miami Beach Council Faces Controversy Over Trolley Contract and Interim City Manager Appointment
- Meeting Overview:
The North Miami Beach City Council meeting on May 31 addressed several issues, including the controversial awarding of a five-year trolley contract without a competitive bidding process and the appointment of an interim city manager amidst disagreements over severance terms for the outgoing manager. Community members expressed their concerns over these decisions, emphasizing the need for transparency and accountability in city governance.
01:46:29A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to the debate over the city’s trolley service contract with ProCal. David Zapen, a resident, criticized the council’s decision to extend the contract for five years without a competitive bidding process, arguing that it deviated from the agenda’s initial presentation of a 90-day renewal. Zapen labeled the council’s actions as lacking transparency and unworthy of public trust, urging for a Request for Proposal (RFP) to ensure a fair and competitive process. Concerns were raised about the allocation of funds from the Citizens’ Independent Transportation Trust (CITT), with Zapen suggesting that these could be better spent on broader community needs like road improvements.
51:25A council member emphasized the need for a competitive bidding process to ensure that the city receives the best value for its taxpayers. They pointed out that the trolley service connects residents to essential locations like Sunny Isles and Aventura, which could be crucial for families without cars. The dialogue also touched on the need for adequate data on trolley usage, particularly during evening hours, to better understand service demand and ensure that the routes effectively meet community needs.
40:11Addressing the interim city manager appointment, the council faced a complex situation regarding the transition from the current manager, whose contract included a potential severance of 20 weeks’ pay, approximately $90,000. There was considerable debate over whether the manager should continue receiving health benefits during his consulting period. A compromise was reached to provide a 15-week severance contingent upon the manager’s continued consulting role. This decision sparked concerns among council members about the financial implications of such a package, particularly in light of the financial hardships facing residents.
15:46Commissioner Smith expressed frustration over the lack of clarity surrounding the manager’s impending departure, emphasizing the need for a structured process in appointing a permanent manager. The city attorney advised that relieving the manager of duties prior to the agreed-upon resignation date could be construed as termination, triggering severance provisions. This further complicated the council’s decision-making process, as members grappled with the implications of appointing an interim manager while addressing the existing manager’s contractual rights.
Residents voiced concerns about the lack of transparency in the council’s decision-making processes, particularly concerning the trolley contract. Emilio Petite, a resident, highlighted infrastructure issues in his neighborhood, including drainage problems and reckless driving, which he urged the city to address promptly. Another speaker, Katie Jasher, advocated for maintaining and improving the trolley service, emphasizing its importance for many residents who rely on it for essential transportation.
04:40:11The meeting also touched on other topics, such as a resolution to cease water fluoridation in line with recent state legislation. While the motion to stop fluoridation passed unanimously, questions were raised about its legality and implications for the city’s water treatment operations. The water director emphasized the need for further guidance from the health department on implementing these changes, noting that immediate cessation of fluoride addition was not straightforward.
Michael Joseph
City Council Officials:
Phyllis Smith, Jay R. Chernoff, Daniela Jean Fortuna, Smukler McKenzie Fleurimond, Lynn Su
-
Meeting Type:
City Council
-
Committee:
-
Meeting Date:
05/20/2025
-
Recording Published:
05/20/2025
-
Duration:
384 Minutes
-
Notability Score:
Noteworthy
Receive debriefs about local meetings in your inbox weekly:
-
State:
Florida
-
County:
Miami-Dade County
-
Towns:
North Miami Beach
Recent Meetings Nearby:
- 06/26/2025
- 06/26/2025
- 25 Minutes
- 06/26/2025
- 06/26/2025
- 135 Minutes
- 06/26/2025
- 06/26/2025
- 12 Minutes