North St. Paul-Maplewood-Oakdale School Board Faces Criticism Over New Sick Time Policy for Paraeducators

The North St. Paul-Maplewood-Oakdale School Board meeting on November 19, 2024, was notably dominated by community concerns over a contentious change in the district’s sick time policy for paraeducators. The decision to require paraeducators to accrue sick leave over time, rather than receiving it upfront, drew significant criticism during the public comment section, with multiple speakers addressing the board to express their discontent and urge reconsideration.

0:00The issue was first brought to light by Jenny Cook, who read a statement from Deborah Toronto, a paraeducator in the pre-K program. Toronto emphasized the financial strain this policy places on staff, stating that it forces a choice between attending work and caring for sick children without income. This sentiment resonated with another speaker, identified as Cindy Swain, who criticized the district for not valuing its paraeducators and highlighted inconsistencies in the treatment of district employees compared to contracted staff.

Adam Horwath, a resource paraeducator and former student of the district, shared his personal narrative of being unable to work due to injuries from an attack last spring. His testimony illustrated the precarious financial situation many paraeducators face without guaranteed sick time. Horwath’s appeal to the board stressed the need for fair treatment and recognition of paraeducators’ contributions.

Alela Pierre Lou, another speaker, highlighted the broader implications of the sick time policy on young adults facing financial instability. Her plea to the board underscored the diverse challenges faced by community members and the significant impact of policy decisions on their lives.

18:07In addition to the public discourse on sick time, the meeting also presented the World’s Best Workforce goals and the district’s progress in areas such as enrollment, student attendance, and academic performance. The report highlighted a decrease in chronic absenteeism, although it remained a concern, particularly among high school students. The district’s efforts to improve readiness for kindergarten were noted, with a focus on early reading and math skills, although goals in these areas were not fully met.

34:51The board reviewed student performance metrics, with emphasis on literacy and mathematics. Only 53% of third-grade students were on track to meet literacy benchmarks, prompting the introduction of a structured literacy framework and a new K-5 curriculum.

The meeting also addressed academic performance in mathematics, revealing slight improvements in proficiency rates. However, disparities among different student groups, particularly those eligible for free and reduced lunch, remained evident. The importance of eighth-grade math as a preparatory step for high school curriculum was emphasized, with ongoing monitoring through district assessments.

Graduation rates were another focal point, with the four-year rate slightly declining, but the seven-year rate surpassing the state average.

51:00The strategic plan for ISD 622, focusing on post-secondary readiness, was discussed, with goals aimed at decreasing the achievement gap and increasing graduation rates. The meeting also addressed the challenges posed by socioeconomic shifts within the district, with discussions on maintaining diversity and the impact of poverty concentration on educational outcomes.

1:24:12Finally, the board acknowledged contributions under Minnesota statute, appointing Julia Martens as an interim board member following a resignation. Plans for future meetings and organizational actions were set, with upcoming presentations on Indian education and other strategic topics.

Note: This meeting summary was generated by AI, which can occasionally misspell names, misattribute actions, and state inaccuracies. This summary is intended to be a starting point and you should review the meeting record linked above before acting on anything you read. If we got something wrong, let us know. We’re working every day to improve our process in pursuit of universal local government transparency.

Receive debriefs about local meetings in your inbox weekly:

Trending meetings
across the country: