The most notable discussion of the evening revolved around a residential property on Oldtown Road, which is reportedly being used as a house of worship, creating significant parking and safety issues for neighbors. A resident, Marielle, raised concerns about the increased traffic and parked cars obstructing mail delivery and emergency vehicle access, particularly on Saturdays and during special events. The council acknowledged these longstanding issues and the complications posed by the property’s tax-exempt status and residential zoning.

One council member recounted a previous meeting with the property’s owner, who stated that the gatherings were social rather than religious. However, residents and council members noted that the gatherings resembled worship services, raising questions about zoning compliance. The council discussed the ambiguity in zoning laws concerning what constitutes a house of worship and the need to consult the zoning officer to determine the property’s compliance with local regulations.

Marielle emphasized the impact on quality of life and safety, urging the council to consider implementing parking restrictions similar to those near the local high school. The council agreed on the need for clearer definitions and guidelines regarding the use of residential properties for worship purposes. They committed to engaging the zoning officer and exploring possible measures to address residents’ concerns while respecting legal frameworks.

In another key topic, the council discussed the appointment of Captain Robert Walked as the officer in charge of the Old Tappan Police Department, effective December 1, 2025, due to the impending retirement of Chief Joseph Tracy. The resolution was aimed at ensuring a smooth transition, although concerns were raised about potential gaps in leadership if the new police chief was not appointed by the end of the year. The council considered designating an interim officer to maintain a clear line of command and ensure continuous leadership.

The council also addressed a proposed plan for constructing a new building at the DPW facility. The project involves a two-phase construction, starting with a two-story living facility featuring offices, locker rooms, bathrooms, and a cafeteria, followed by demolishing the existing building and creating a new mechanical workspace. Financial implications were a point of contention, with cost estimates ranging from one to five million dollars. An alternative proposal suggested using a recently constructed building on Chestnut Street, which already contains necessary amenities.

Community events and activities were also discussed, with updates provided on upcoming events such as the annual Christmas tree lighting and recent successes in youth sports. The council expressed interest in recognizing local achievements by inviting championship-winning soccer teams to a future meeting.

Additional topics included the management of the local deer population, with discussions on non-lethal methods and interest from the United Bow Hunters. The council acknowledged the need for a collaborative approach with neighboring towns and considered inviting the bow hunters to present their strategies in February.