Palatka City Manager Terminated Amidst Controversy, New Interim Appointed
- Meeting Overview:
In a development during the Palatka City Commission meeting, the employment of City Manager Marcia Cardi was terminated. The move followed a motion citing unfulfilled commitments, including a lack of engagement with a coaching city manager and the absence of planned workshops aimed at boosting employee morale. The decision, which was made after a robust public comment session, highlighted a divide within the community regarding Cardi’s performance and the process leading to her termination. The commission subsequently appointed Chief Shaw as the interim city manager.
The termination of Marcia Cardi, who had served as city manager, was a focal point of contention. Some attendees voiced strong opposition to the termination, arguing that Cardi had been effective in her role and that the decision lacked transparency. Others supported the move, pointing to unfulfilled commitments as a justification for her dismissal.
The appointment of Chief Shaw as the interim city manager raised questions about the legality of serving in dual roles as both the chief of police and acting city manager. Concerns were addressed, and assurances were provided that holding both positions would not lead to legal complications. This temporary appointment aims to maintain stability within the city’s administration as the commission navigates the transition.
The meeting also featured discussions on the status of the Port Consolidated site, with a commissioner introducing an emergency item regarding potential state funding assistance. The proposed funding, amounting to $300,000, is intended for site assessment and remediation, and the urgency of the matter was emphasized due to the recent receipt of relevant documentation. The funding opportunity is part of existing obligations, and its discussion at the meeting was seen as a procedural necessity.
Moreover, the commission addressed the annexation request for a parcel located on Mission Road. This request aimed to connect the property to city water services, which necessitated its annexation. The planning board had reviewed the request, confirming compliance with relevant statutes and zoning codes. However, concerns about urban sprawl and the implications of annexing properties surrounded by county land were raised. A motion was made to table the annexation request until the next meeting.
Another topic was the revision of the city’s hiring policies, which had not been updated for several years. The proposed updates aim to clarify the hiring process, including structured interviews and the evaluation of internal candidates for promotions. Concerns were raised about the specificity of the proposed changes, with commissioners emphasizing the need for clarity to ensure consistency in hiring procedures.
The meeting also touched on the management of special events, with a commissioner proposing a strategy to address issues with timely submissions for event approvals. The proposal suggested a streamlined process with specific timelines for different classes of events to prevent delays and confusion. Discussions also addressed the reliance on law enforcement for event security and the consistency of security measures across events.
Lastly, the commission considered changes to the structure of the city’s boards and committees, including the reduction of planning board members from nine to five. This adjustment aims to streamline operations and improve efficiency. The commission also discussed the reappointment process following the resignation of a commissioner from the Community Redevelopment Agency board, emphasizing the need for adherence to established resolutions and procedures.
Robbi Correa
City Council Officials:
Tammie McCaskill, Justin Campbell, Will Jones, Rufus Borom
-
Meeting Type:
City Council
-
Committee:
-
Meeting Date:
04/23/2026
-
Recording Published:
04/23/2026
-
Duration:
225 Minutes
-
Notability Score:
Noteworthy
Receive debriefs about local meetings in your inbox weekly:
-
State:
Florida
-
County:
Putnam County
-
Towns:
Palatka
Recent Meetings Nearby:
- 06/25/2026
- 06/25/2026
- 277 Minutes
- 06/24/2026
- 06/24/2026
- 227 Minutes
- 06/24/2026
- 06/24/2026
- 19 Minutes